Air Date: 11-17-2026
Today we look at the Democrats' historic wave election. The last time both houses of Congress were flipped in the same year was 2006, the first election the Democrats ran on the 50-state strategy. We dig into this year's election results, analyze what they mean, help chart a course for the future, and pull some deep cuts from 2006 to hear what it sounded like when the 50-state strategy was being built the first time around.
Books from this episode (affiliate links support our work):
This week's guests discuss their new books:
Minority Rule by Ari Berman: print at Bookshop.org · audiobook at Libro.fm
Brown Is the New White by Steve Phillips: print at Bookshop.org
The Blueprint by Bhaskar Sunkara, Ben Burgis and Mike Beggs: print at Bookshop.org · audiobook at Libro.fm
We Are Indivisible by Leah Greenberg and Ezra Levin: print at Bookshop.org · audiobook at Libro.fm
Overcoming Trumpery edited by Norm Eisen: print at Bookshop.org
The Case for Impeaching Trump by Elizabeth Holtzman: print at Bookshop.org · audiobook at Libro.fm
You Have the Power by Howard Dean: print at Bookshop.org
Full transcript coming soon!
Welcome to this episode of the award-winning Best of the Left podcast. We curate the best progressive thinkers speaking on the most important issues into themed episodes that are greater than the sum of their parts.
Everyone knows by now that the Democrats had a historic wave election this month, making inroads into Republican strongholds that very few thought possible. The last time both houses of Congress were flipped in the same year was 2006, when an unpopular Republican president mired in war faced a midterm election during his second term. That also happens to be the first election the Democrats ran on the 50-state strategy, spearheaded by DNC chair and 2004 presidential candidate who was written off and considered unfit because he vocalized his enthusiasm in just slightly the wrong way, Howard Dean. It was a very different time.
2006 also happens to be the first year that I was producing Best of the Left, which means that we can dig into this year's election results, analyze what they mean, help chart a course for the future, and also pull some deep cuts from 2006 and hear what it sounded like when the 50-state strategy was being built and implemented the first time around.
People who are good at math may also recall that 2006 came just two years before 2008, when there was another type of historic election when people finally had the opportunity to replace an administration that had long outstayed its welcome. One could, and probably should, argue that the momentum from 2006 very much helped carry over into 2008. There are lessons to be learned there as well, as the Democrats use these next two years to make a statement about what the party stands for and what it's willing to fight for to give their next presidential candidate the platform they will need to make real change if elected.
This episode was 20 years in the making. We're going to highlight the joy and satisfaction that comes with victory after a hard-fought battle, and appreciate the deep work and commitment required over a long time and spread out everywhere, without taking any wins or losses as predetermined. I'll also have some thoughts on what this should mean for the next two to four years, given our experience the last time these same sorts of dynamics were at play.
For those looking for a quick overview, the sources providing our Top Takes in about 55 minutes today include
The PBS NewsHour
Democracy Now!
More Perfect Union
Stress Test
Why, America with Leeja Miller
The Daily Beans
What A Day
and No Lie with Brian Tyler Cohen
Then, in the additional, Deeper Dives half of the show, there'll be more in 4 sections;
Section A, The Congressional Mandate
Section B, Power in the States
Section C, Anatomy of the Wave
And Section D, Lessons and Warnings
For every way to connect with and support us, check out our link in bio in the show notes.
And now, on to the show.
Democrats Ride 'blue Wave' After Midterm Elections - PBS Newshour - Air Date 11-4-26
I think tonight we saw a historic election across this country where people are coming out like never before and demanding a government that works for them. We must deliver for working people, Maine people, and the American people.
We just proved that all the money in the world is no match for the people of Texas
We just showed that a politics of division is no match for a politics of love.
I refuse to accept that my two little girls will grow up in a world as dark and dangerous and cruel as this one threatens to become. I'll tell her how the same year she turned five, Georgia overcame every doubt and dirty trick, not just to win, but to set a new course for our state and our country and our world.
South Carolina, my name may have been on the ballot, but this victory doesn't belong to me. It belongs to all of you.
Because tonight we here in South Carolina sent a clear message that this Senate seat does not belong to one family, one party, or to Washington, DC.
As your senator, I will always put you, the people of North Carolina, first. I will put you before politics. I'll put you before party. I will put you before power.
I'm not going to Washington to be something. I'm going to Washington to do something.
Purple Mississippi? Overcoming GOP Voter Suppression, Black Voters Power Dem Wins Across the South Part 1 - Democracy Now! - Air Date 11-5-26
We begin today's show in the deep south, where Mississippi's senate race remains too close to call.
Democrat Scott Colom is narrowly leading Republican incumbent Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith by more than 1,800 votes as election officials process provisional ballots and late-arriving mail ballots. Just two years ago, Donald Trump carried Mississippi by 23 points. If elected, Scott Colom would be the first Democrat to win the state in 40 years and the first African American since 1875 during Reconstruction.
Colom made the issue of affordability central to his campaign, and in an ad that went viral, he blasted Senator Hyde-Smith for saying Mississippians should, quote, "Pick another protein," unquote, if they're upset over high beef prices. The ad features Mississippians saying they'd rather pick another senator.
The going price of beef continuing to go up. you have so many proteins to choose from.
Pick another protein? that. I'd rather pick another senator instead.
Pick another protein? She done lost her damn mind. I'd rather pick another senator. Pick
another protein? What the ?
Pick another senator instead.
Scott Colom is a former district attorney for northeast Mississippi. In 2022, President Biden nominated him to the federal bench, a nomination blocked by Colom's opponent in this race, incumbent Republican senator Cindy Hyde-Smith. Colom has sharply criticized national Democrats for writing off Mississippi and failing to invest in his campaign early on.
He told reporters, quote, "Mississippi was never a lost cause. We were a betrayed cause." This is Colom speaking to NBC News.
The reality is our country does not do well when it ignores places like Mississippi. You can't lead with doubt. You have to believe. You have to lead with belief, and that's where the power is.
When you believe things, you can actually achieve it. And there's some people in the party that they are just treading water, right? What's the path to least resistance to get to 51? Oh my gosh, we did it. That's not the right way to think. In this particular moment, you have to think about how can we win everywhere because we need to represent working people in a way where we actually deliver.
The potential electoral upset in Mississippi is part of a much broader political shift across the South, where Democrats have scored major victories in states long considered Republican strongholds. For the latest on Mississippi and more on the seat change in the South, we're joined by two guests. In Durham, North Carolina, we're joined by Chris Crump, the executive director of the Institute for Southern Studies, publisher of its online magazine, Facing South.
And we're joined by Cliff Albright, co-founder of Black Voters Matter. He's been in Jackson, Mississippi for much of this week, including election night, but now back in Atlanta, Georgia, where we've spoken to him many times before. We welcome you both to Democracy Now! Cliff Albright, let's begin with you.
To say the least, Colom feels betrayed by the Democratic Party for not backing him sooner, and yet he has shocked the nation, in being ahead, in this very narrowly, in this race where he may be, though it's not finalized yet, unseating the incumbent senator Cindy Hyde-Smith. Tell us what happened in Mississippi.
Yeah. Good morning, Amy, and, and good morning to my good friend Chris. yeah, you all may not be able to claim it, but we're claiming it. He's claiming it. He's, he's ahead. He's been ahead since election night. his lead continues to grow as they continue to count absentee ballots. we're continuing many organizations.
It's an incredible coalition of organizations down there in Mississippi, that are fighting right now to make sure that every vote gets counted. People that were forced to do affidavit ballots or provisional ballots, in some states it's known as, trying to get organized to make sure that all of those ballots get, get counted.
People that didn't have ID get their ballots fixed, get the ballots cured to get all those votes counted. So we believe that he's winning, and at the end of the, at the end of the day, that he's going to be the winner. But what happened is, in spite of, the rest of the country really ignoring Mississippi
And I, and I do, gotta say that in addition to Mississippi, the points that he made about that state, the same could be said about Louisiana, which got even less support than his race got and still came within a razor-thin margin. The same could be said about Florida, right? Alabama. All of these states, have been ignored, have been under-resourced, under-invested.
There are amazing groups doing, doing work on a shoestring budget. But because of the tide of Black voter enthusiasm, largely fed by the Supreme Court's Calais decision, which gutted the Voting Rights Act, ever since that decision, we've seen a wave of organizing, a wave of momentum. Of all the shifts that took place in the, in the country, and to be clear, the entire country shifted left, but when you look at it regionally, the biggest shifts took place in the South.
Texas, Mississippi, South Carolina, Louisiana, all those points had shifts between 20 and 24 points. And so the, the wave of energy, largely led by Black voters who were most under attack with the mid-decade racial gerrymandering that was taking place, it clearly backfired, and all it did was to, to wake up a sleeping giant.
and Chris Krom, I wanted to a- ask you your reaction to the, results in Mississippi, and if you could talk a little bit about the history of the two candidates
No, absolutely. And an incredible year for Democrats in the South. the story of Scott Collum in Mississippi is one of the most remarkable.
here you have a longtime, leader in, in the Black community in Mississippi up against a longtime, Republican. And the history that you brought out was incredibly important to the, as backdrop to this race where, he was put forward as a federal district nominee from the Biden administration in the fall of 2022, and almost every politician in Mississippi backed him, including the Republican senator Roger Wicker.
But, the one person who blocked his nomination is the current, senator for Mississippi, Cindy Hyde-Smith. And what you see there is... so there's a, a personal history there . and, e- she really seemed determined. she thought she had this race. She was phoning it in. and, the- to their credit, the Democrats I think late in the game kind of realized that this is a race that could be won.
and what you're seeing now I think is really interesting, where, armies of lawyers have come to Mississippi. The Republican lawyers are saying that they wanna segregate those ballots, pull them aside that came in, the affidavit ballots, or called provisional ballots elsewhere in the country, and pull those aside.
Democratic lawyers and, civil rights lawyers are saying that that's not something you can do in Mississippi. And so this is really turning out to be an important legal battle. But as Cliff said, the trend lines are all going in the direction of Collum. And given that personal history, but also the long political history in Mississippi, it would be truly historic, if he can come out on top
a- and Chris, in other states, the, the, the victories by Democrats at the top of the ticket have had an impact on the, on other races, less high-profile races.
What's happened there in Mississippi?
Yeah. Well, I think that's something really important to understand is that these Senate races, so there's, if, Scott Collum wins, which I think is very likely, that'll be six Democrats who have won statewide s- US Senate races. And those races really drove a lot of turnout that benefited, played a role in the US congressional races and statewide races.
and so you see that playing down the ballot where this overall shift, as Cliff noted, that there was a 20-point shift overall in the South when you look at the '24 presidential vote to what happened in the Senate races, a 20-point shift in the Democratic vote margin from 24 to 26, and that played out all down the ballot.
And even in races where, as Cliff notes, the places where Democrats came up short, what it really showed was the possibility of what's possible in southern states, and I think that's gonna change forever people's ideas about what the political map looks like nationally and the importance of the South in driving the national political agenda.
What the Media Is Missing About Democrats’ Midterm Victories - More Perfect Union - Air Date 11-6-26
At the time, during Trump's first year of his second term, two different visions were playing out within the Democratic Party.
As Donald Trump and Elon Musk were torching government services- Torch all ... firing government employees-
That's not a job that's gonna make America great again ...
and courting the nation's elite, one faction of the Democratic Party said, "Play dead. Do nothing."
My point is,
just lay back, play possum.
And arose a different faction within the Democratic Party, the economic populists, who said, "Fight the oligarchy."
I used to talk about oligarchy and people say, "What is he talking about?" Everybody knows what I'm talking about tonight.
At the same time, Zohran Mamdani was polling at all of 1% in New York, but of course, that would soon change.
Tonight, you have delivered a mandate for change, a mandate for a new kind of politics, a mandate for a city we can afford, and a mandate for a government that delivers exactly that.
What Zohran Mamdani's amazing campaign in New York showed is how to win working class people across the spectrum, even as he was derided by big moneyed interests and many of the media elite as being a far left agenda.
And I'm sure Republicans- Yeah ... look at what Zohran Mamdani just said yesterday and say, "Please say more of that, because that does give us an opening in the midterm elections."
Those who are paying attention keenly were taking notes, and they were changing the way that they were talking. James Carville, by late November, is saying that economic populism needs to be the message of all Democrats, and the campaign started to change too.
The only minority destroying America is the billionaires.
This chart of ad spending on issue by issue is a good shorthand for how much Democrats centered affordability and economic populism this year. Two years ago, the top ad issues for Democrats looked very different, with Trump's character among the top five issues for both Senate and House race ad buys.
That economic prism of talking about class-based issues pervaded all Democratic campaigns.
Gallons of gas, gallons of milk. Trump and Rogers could care less how much these things cost.
I am so tired of working people being told that we should settle for scraps while the richest people in this country get permanent relief.
That is all backwards.
Across Alaska, we are getting crushed
by
corporate greed.
The biggest corporations and the richest Americans have grabbed unimaginable wealth at your expense.
In my view, economic populism is defined by a few core things. First, you have to be willing to take on people with power.
To drive private equity out of housing, healthcare, nursing homes.
Name the villain.
We're all being taken advantage of by big tech, by these data centers. I'm Dr. Annie Andrews. I'll go after big insurance companies overcharging you and ripping us off.
When big pharma raised your bills, I took them on. Who are we up against? Who is depriving us of economic power?
Elon Musk wants our land, he wants our water, he wants our tax dollars, and he wants his very own personal United States senator.
Second, what specific agenda items do you wanna put on the docket to improve the lives of working class Americans?
Money out of-
Pocket.
Money in your- Pocket. Medicare for- All. That's right.
Ban them from denying care a doctor says you need. I wanna expand Medicare to cover vision, dental, and hearing.
Stopping these stupid wars around the world so that we can bring our money and resources home and invest in housing we can all afford, healthcare we can count on, and social security.
And third, how are you building a grassroots movement that reflects the emotions of the working class people, their anger, their frustrations?
In this election cycle, Republicans largely hid from public view.
When there were town halls, he walked out of that. So you're not actually listening and hearing people's pain.
Abdul El-Sayed held over 700 public events in Michigan alone.
If any of you came here and you were angry and upset, I was gonna listen to that, too, and I've had church people angry and upset with me.
I don't walk out of the room when people are angry or upset.
James Talarico did hundreds of events in Texas.
No, you stay here, you answer our questions, or you suffer the consequences.
I appreciate you being here, and I appreciate you traveling in, and I appreciate you-
I did it for my people, not for
me.
Wonderful. And that's wonderful. It's all right. It's all right. It's all right. This is, this is what this conversation's supposed to be about.
This is how Democrats won, by talking to working class people, hearing their pain, anger, and frustration, and channeling that towards an economic agenda to improve their lives.
One cautionary note about the election day outcomes is that while individual Democratic candidates did well, the Democratic Party brand is still suffering, with majorities disapproving of it. Democratic Party leadership did not come forward with a specific agenda to offer working class people in this election cycle.
It was left to individual candidates themselves to form agendas to speak to the working class people of their states. The opportunity now is to present an agenda that speaks for a Democratic Party writ large, and it's not going to come from the Democratic leadership that we have. Here are five things Democrats should do if they want to remain the party of the working class.
These agenda items, mind you, are wildly popular in Texas, Georgia, Kansas, Michigan, and everywhere else the Democrats won on election night. First, end the wars. If we're gonna be serious about ending the wars, we need to leverage ending the funding for those wars. Second, raise the cap on taxable income on Social Security.
Make billionaires pay their fair share so that we can expand Social Security benefits for working class Americans. Third, raise the minimum wage to a living wage. Fourth, break up Big Medicine's corporate monopolies and provide better healthcare for more people. And fifth, rein in the power of the Big Tech oligarchs.
Protect communities from unchecked data center development and create new AI safety guardrails.
We sent a crystal clear message to the people at the top. We will not be conquered. Michigan, we did it!
I, I, I think we just made some history.
Let's be clear. The biggest overriding issue of this election cycle was Donald Trump's corruption and his lack of action on anything to improve working class people's lives.
In order for economic populace to win against this backdrop, you had to provide a sense that you were focused on economic issues. And against a media discourse that is often pitting identity politics to distract one candidate or another, we saw across the board, candidates focused on talking about healthcare, talking about the economy, talking about AI and data center development.
They were doing so in ways that were focused and attentive to economic pain and suffering. They may have talked about those issues in slightly different ways. Not all candidates were for Medicare for All, but all candidates were talking about healthcare expansion. Not all candidates were taxing the rich in specific ways, but all candidates were for raising the tax rates on the wealthiest in society.
Discussing economic justice issues and being focused on economic populism while Donald Trump had nothing to offer the working class people of this country, provided the path to win enormous victories.
America to Trump You're a Loser - Stress Test - Air Date 11-4-26
Ari, we know, we've talked to you in the past about how they were trying to rig the playing field for this election, the Republicans, with gerrymandering and often racist gerrymandering.
So what happened?
They completely failed. this was the central strategy of Donald Trump to try to keep the House. The mid-decade gerrymandering we saw in the last two years aided by the US Supreme Court's dismantling of the Voting Rights Act, and it was almost a complete and total failure. They tried to draw five safe seats in Texas.
They didn't get anywhere close to that. They might lose all five of those seats as we're recording. They tried to draw four- Hold
on. Emphasize that. I w- I wanna g- I want, I want to... I... Like a fine wine, I wanna savor this.
w- we
Just tell us that again.
After, after- If
you can even use the same words.
After all we've seen- Tell us that again ... after all we've seen, we have to savor it S- they tried to draw five safe Republican seats in Texas. This is how this all started. Last year, Trump said he was entitled to five new Republican seats in Texas. It looks very possible they're gonna lose all five of those districts.
In Florida, Ron DeSantis, the Republican governor, pressured Florida Republicans to dre- redraw their map to get four new Republican seats. They lost all four of them. In Alabama, they racially gerrymandered to oust Shamarie Figgers, who was elected in 2024. For the first time, there were two Black members of Congress for Alabama.
He won reelection in a district that they drew to get rid of him, and so this was remarkable. We're still processing the results, but there's other states where this backfired. Looks like North Carolina's one of them. there's other places in which, they thought they could hold seats and they didn't.
So this was just one example, of how Trump's strategy failed, and I think more broadly, the gerrymandering and the dismantling of the VRA led to a much larger turnout among Black voters in 2026. That's,
that's the Voting Rights Act, for people who don't pay as much attention as you
do. Yes. The dismantling of the Voting Rights Act in Louisiana v.
Kelly decision led to a huge turnout of Black voters during early voting. We saw that continue on election day, and that's why you saw such massive victories all across the South, in Georgia, in South Carolina, in North Carolina, in Florida, in Texas. This would've been impossible without a mobilized Black vote, and also major shifts in the Latino vote and younger voters and other demographics.
And to me, this backlash against the destruction of the Voting Rights Act and the larger failure of Republican gerrymandering is one of the defining issues of this election.
Yeah. Of course, this is a reminder, at the, at the time of recording, we don't have results for all of these races, but there's a race that I've been paying very close attention to.
Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Tennessee's 9th Congressional District. This is, the district that used to just be a very highly compact district there in the corner, the, the far west corner of Tennessee, Memphis, Tennessee. they cracked that district into three separate districts, and Justin J. Pearson is running there.
He is currently, at the time of recording, he is currently ahead. Now, 84% of, of the votes have been counted, so we'll see how this thing c- pans out, but he's currently ahead. this was a total miscalculation- Mm-hmm ... Ari, it seems, across so many of these districts that they thought were going to be easy pickings for them.
And so what I'm curious about is how you expect for Republicans to respond to some of this. Obviously, the districts that they drew were weaker than they anticipated. How, what, what mechanism do they have to respond after tonight?
Well, my hope is they just drop it altogether and realize how how, how- Whoops.
Whoops ... my hope is that they drop it because they realize how unpopular it was, and how it, it didn't actually work. Now, th- there may be a few districts. They, they may end up flipping that Tennessee district. They're gonna end up flipping a, a district in Louisiana and eliminating one majority Black district in Louisiana.
So I, I don't wanna minimize the casualties that exist, but by and large, they tried to draw 15 new Republican districts, and they didn't get anywhere close to that. And if you look at the seats that Democrats redrew in retaliation, in California, for example, Democrats, Democrats could actually net seats at the end of this in terms of redistricting.
So I hope they drop it. My fear, however, is they're gonna double down on it, and they're gonna say that we need to now do this in more places. But the flip side is they've lost power in a lot of places. Yep. They lost the North Carolina State House, one of the most gerrymandered state legislatures in the country.
They can't gerrymander in North Carolina anymore. Yep. They may lose the Texas legislature. Yes. I cannot stress enough how crazy that is. Insane. Insane. That they might lose it. Yeah. They can't gerrymander in Texas. In Georgia, they could try to do lame duck gerrymandering. We'll see.
Man, this is just such a- But-
be careful what you wish for situation, right? They thought they were so darn clever and that, and th- they were doing Trump's bidding here to rig the election field, to make the Republican majority permanent, and basically Trumpism would l- would live on forever. And yet the best laid plans of mice and men and racist Republicans-
Right
often go astray
I th- yeah,
I think the p- the voters s- saw a connection between all the things they didn't like in Washington, the fact that Trump wasn't paying attention to all the issues they cared about, and the attempt to rig the political system. they saw, okay, they're not lowering gas prices, they're not ending the war, they're not making anything more affordable.
What are they doing? They're rigging the districts to try to choose their own electorate. And so I, I think it just pissed people off, and I think it pissed a lot of different people off. Black voters in the South, Latino voters in the Sun Belt, younger voters. I think there was a broad rejection, of, of the effort to try to rig the game, and, and that led to anger about corruption, which was related to this, 'cause this is one way corruption plays out, right?
Trying to choose your own electorate. This was, this was a broad rejection of the Republican Party's attempt to rig the political system, whether it was to rig the political maps, try to buy elections- Mm-hmm ... try to run a plutocratic government. All of that was connected in terms of why voters rejected Republican candidates tonight.
A Historic Election (And What Comes Next) Part 1 - Why, America with Leeja Miller - Air Date 11-4-26
you're allowed to be happy and hopeful. I know it's like a trendy thing to be cynical, and I'm not trying to poop on your parade, but as I always, always say, voting is literally the least you could do when it comes to civic engagement and participation.
And our elected officials have proven time and time again that they are corruptible and that they won't do what the people want them to do unless we hold their feet to the fucking fire So we celebrate, and then we get back to work making sure they know what we expect of them, because one of my biggest qualms with Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries and the Democratic establishment is how much they've fucking rolled over in the last decade, how little vision they actually have for America.
The reason why people are fired up about Abdul El-Sayed, and about Zuhairah Mamdani, and about AOC and Bernie is because they offer solutions and hope for a better future in a way that the Democratic establishment is completely incapable of. All we have ever gotten out of Jeffries and Schumer are meaningless platitudes and absolutely no vision or follow-through, which is what was on display in their victory speeches that I just showed you.
Trump is awful, and his policies are horrific, and I will never lie to you and say the two parties are exactly the same. If we had elected Kamala Harris, none of the worst of this would be happening. Rene Goode and Alex Preddie would still be alive, for example. But even on a good year in the US, we are selecting between two right-leaning capitalist moderates who wanna keep the status quo and avoid rocking the boat so they keep their funding intact and their wealthy friends happy.
Yes, this includes Obama. Obama literally ran on hope, and I know I felt it, and all we got was a healthcare bill that's mostly been gutted, a ton of deportations, and some bombs over Yemen. Oh, and the wealth inequality has only been growing. Frankly, the only beacon of hope and light coming from Democratic leadership over the last couple of decades has been my queen Lina Khan's brief role in the FTC attempting to go after monopolists and enforce the antitrust laws on the books.
Sorry, that's it. And guess what? She went on to work for Zuhairah Mamdani. Okay, so now that the Democrats are about to take over, they need to be ready to hit the ground running. They have a couple months to plan, and reports are saying that Trump and Russell Vote and Stephen Miller and his other goons have been scheming in the background for the past few months, planning how to continue to expand executive power like they've already been doing, even with Democratic control of Congress.
Something tells me Democrats have not been doing the same level of scheming for what they're gonna do when the power gets back into their hands. So let's talk about what they can and should do. First, Democrats should elect different majority leaders for both the House and the Senate. They don't have to choose Schumer and Jeffries.
They do not know how to connect with American voters. They do not have compelling visions for the future. They have proven incompetent as opposition leaders during Trump's second term. They should lose their jobs as leaders of the Democratic party. If you agree with me, you should reach out to your newly elected or reelected Congress members, urging them to select more compelling leadership.
They have that power, and they will be making that decision on who to vote in as majority leader very soon. Beyond that, of course, Congress has the power to investigate governmental corruption and other high crimes and misdemeanors. Impeachment for Trump is definitely on the table, but the House impeaches and the Senate convicts and removes from office.
And even with 55 Democratic senators, that's not enough to meet the two-thirds threshold to actually remove Trump from office. Trump's popularity is waning, even among Republicans, but I doubt that they have the numbers to officially remove him from office. And as we saw the first time around, an impeachment in the House doesn't really do anything to actually stop Trump.
The likely next step would be to impeach and remove his cabinet. Efforts to do so have already begun in the House, specifically aimed at Pete Hegseth, RFK Jr., and Education Secretary Linda McMahon. The process is largely the same as for the president. They can be impeached for treason, bribery, and high crimes and misdemeanors.
A majority of the House has to vote to impeach, and then a trial is held in the Senate, after which two-thirds have to vote to remove the person. The House would start by launching investigations into these people, and I don't think it'll be hard to find evidence of bribery or other crimes and misdemeanors committed by any one of Trump's cabinet members.
Trump's advisors in the White House, who are not approved by the Senate, are a little harder to get at. But the Constitution gives Congress the right to impeach civil officers of the United States, and it's arguable who counts as a civil officer. Experts have made compelling legal arguments as to why Congress should have the ability to impeach Trump's White House advisors, like Russell Vote and Stephen Miller.
And Congress should also release and un-redact all of the Epstein files, other than victim names, including those pertaining to Trump, which could sway any future impeachment and trial against him if there's some smoking gun evidence in there. So in short, Democrats in Congress should plan on day one to begin investigating Trump, but also his cabinet members and his advisors, because the level of corruption and bribery that's been happening across the federal government under Trump's watch and with Trump's direct involvement is so blatant and obvious that it frankly shouldn't be hard for them to make a case for removal of a lotta different people.
And I think that the American people want that. They want retribution. They want a Nuremberg-style -ile event to hold these people accountable. As much as I wanna also move forward and push Democrats to give us an actual vision of a hopeful future, I think Congress's investigation powers are important for holding the Trump administration to account.
Now, the Supreme Court has given Trump pretty much carte blanche to break the law, and as long as he's president, there's nothing that can be done about it from a criminal prosecution standpoint. But the people under Trump do not have that protection. State attorneys general that have potential cases should absolutely ramp up their investigations, and their cases may be aided by findings in congressional investigations.
Trump's personal lawyer still controls the Department of Justice, so any federal criminal probe would have to wait until a Democrat takes office in the presidency before any sort of criminal prosecution would move forward against various members of Trump's cabinet and his advisors. I'm thinking specifically, for example, of Jared Kushner, who was so clearly engaged in self-dealing that there's no way they couldn't build a white-collar criminal case against him, allegedly.
The criminal prosecution side of things is, however, outside the scope of what Congress can do right away. So they should begin investigations, but that cannot be the only thing they do, and that's where I'm afraid that they'll stop. Because again, Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries have offered no concrete substantive plans for the future.
They have spent the last decade simply pointing at how bad Trump is while doing absolutely fuck all to actually make people's day-to-day lives better. So I'm hoping that the momentum from the progressive wins in this election cycle will translate into some actual policy initiatives that could improve people's lives right away. My worry is that Trump has said that he's gonna be Mr. Veto and that the Democratic establishment is gonna use that as a cop-out to get absolutely nothing done. "Well, what's the point? He's gonna veto it," as if it doesn't matter to us to see our elected representatives actually advocating for us no matter what, as if sitting on their hands is what we wanna see them doing.
Again, it's about messaging. It's about providing a compelling vision of a future where average people in America can thrive in a way they cannot right now. Make Trump veto that vision and that future. Make him say no to it on the record. Do it anyway, and then run on that vision next time. Run on that record next time.
That is how you build momentum. That's how you show the American people you're actually working for them, something that Schumer and Jeffries are incapable of doing.
The Accountability Economy (feat. Hilary Braseth) - The Daily Beans - Air Date 11-11-26
I always like to go back a little bit to the beginning. Many people have heard of OpenSecrets or have read numbers cited by our work in news articles, and very few actually know the origin story of this organization, which goes back actually to the '80s. In a post-Watergate era, there were a lot of laws that got set up in the United States to help regulate- Against corruption.
And a good chunk of those were specifically around elections and lobbying, and just the murky waters that exist between capitalism and democracy. During that time, two senators across opposite sides of the aisle, a very novel phenomenon these days- ... collaborated on basically their viewpoint, which was that money itself was a growing variable in the policy-making process, and they felt very strongly that that information needed to be made public.
So back in the '80s, OpenSecrets was first born, and our first foray was actually a book. You could go to the library and look up your member of Congress. The thing was three inches thick and 1,500 pages long, and you could see who funded your member of Congress. You could also look up a company and see how they lobbied.
Now, these books fondly are doorsteps for us, in our office. but when the- ... when the internet was born in the '90s, we digitized all of that data and were pretty much pioneers in setting up a website back in those days, next year will be our 30th birthday as a website, and made that data available to reporters, journalists, folks that wanted to cover this information and make it part of the accountability ecosystem.
So in modern times, we've evolved significantly. So when you ask, where do we get this information and why is it important, our ethos and our mission are really that transparency is a cornerstone of this democratic experiment being able to function. And so with- without knowing the silent but magnanimous forces that might be shaping either voters' viewpoints in the forms of ads or politicians in the way that they vote, or in the way that they grant government contracts for large sums of money, we really do run the risk of eventually living in a system of either, some might call it crony capitalism, or some might call it, a democracy that really just is, being pulled by the strings of large financial interests, and not really a government of, by, and for the people, which is really what a founding ethos of this nation stated.
Yeah. No, agreed. And, and why do you think it is that it just seemed to hit home in after 2024? Like Elon Musk's spending, for example, had a lot more impact in 2024, at least, if you're just looking at the results of elections and things like that. Like you said, you've been doing this since the '80s.
So what shifted recently to, cause people to pay more attention to this or, or be more aware of it, do you think?
I think there are a few forces. What's interesting is Musk spent back in '24 what we thought was an outrageous amount of money, and he spent even more this cycle. And I think increasingly, and we've seen this over the history of us following this as well, you certainly need a lot of money to be a viable candidate, but you don't necessarily need the most money.
And in fact, having the most money can sometimes backfire for candidates. you also need a good candidate. You need charisma, you need timing, you need the zeitgeist, you need clear communications to voters. and so in this specific cycle, there's a chance that Musk might have just been backing a losing candidate from, from jump.
In addition, he became the message, and Talarico really in Texas campaigned against billionaires buying elections and named Musk directly. And so if harnessed in the right ways, that can really incense voters, who, by the way, with an overwhelming majority across both sides of the aisle, really dislike the amount of money in politics.
Within more than 80% polling data tells us that Democrats and Republican voters think there's way too much money going into this thing. And so I think increasingly that might eventually become a liability for the folks who have a lot of money.
Yeah, and at the center of it all, telling us about every penny spent and where it's spent for the last 30 years that your website's been online, and before that with books, is, OpenSecrets.
it's... I don't think there's a, a person listening right now that hasn't heard reference to opensecrets.org or used it themselves to find out where the money is going, and that's why I think shining a light on it is so important. Talk a little bit about how... 'Cause, you just mentioned briefly, Talarico ran against a notoriously terrible candidate and used the spending that was coming into the other side, a lot of, a lot of candidates did this, to communicate that and, and make it more obvious.
How else can people shine a light on the kind of money that's being spent that you track, that you're tracking every election cycle?
Yeah. We always encourage folks to get curious and explore our site. It sometimes can be overwhelming. There's a lot of data to dig into. The other thing I like to tell people is this whole notion of influence is not an every two or four-year process.
Money in politics is 365 days a year, round the clock, and there's nowhere better to see that than our website. Candidates start fundraising for their campaigns the year before the election even is about to occur. Furthermore, we have this whole vector called lobbying, and that- ... nowhere else than there is it more blatant to understand how that works in this country and being able to dive into any company's lobbying record.
You could search any corporation, see who they're hiring for lobbyists, how much are they spending, how does that compare year over year, what are they lobbying on in terms of bills in Congress? So there's a whole treasure trove of ways for you as an i- individual or, an average citizen to get informed and to share this with other folks.
this can become, useful in shaping advocacy strategy to counter moneyed interests, and ultimately to help fuel local and national news outlets that make sure that- They're reporting in an accountable fashion and in investigative research that they have the right fact-based information to share.
Yeah, and talking about forming those strategies, we saw Montana this cycle vote to basically overturn Citizens United in their state. if, if our Supreme Court is gonna be like, "Well, let the states decide on whatever." But now we've got 28, I think, Democratic governorships, more than we've had. We haven't had the majority in 16 years, so now I think states and state legislatures, well, we've got five new flips and all the, broken super majorities.
I think people can start looking at ways that states can use the kind of data that OpenSecrets puts out in order to develop policy or legislation to keep money out of politics, right?
Yeah, what's happening at the state level across the country is really interesting. There's a lot of dynamism happening at the state level specifically because there is this law of the land from the Supreme Court Citizens United decision.
What's interesting about Montana is they're tackling it from the angle of not amending the campaign finance law, but rather trying to amend the corporate code in the state to essentially not allow them from being able to contribute in elections. So a really interesting one to watch for sure. I would also say that, for the first time in history- We have a combined database at OpenSecrets.
There was a merger back in 2021 between two nonprofit entities, one which was heavily focused on gathering all the state data, and one which is focused on all the federal data. So in the last few years, we've been painstakingly stitching those two gargantuan datasets together to talk to one another. And, in the last month, we just launched all of our state and federal combined data on our website.
So you can now click on any state, say Montana, and see across your governor races, your state legislative races, state supreme court in states where those positions are elected, and also able to solicit donations, a whole host of information on the state level, but also the federal level all in one place.
Yeah. So if you're in a state and you want to maybe start the idea of blocking corporate funding to campaigns, OpenSecrets is, is now, because of this merger, you'll be able to get drilled down data on spending on state races where you live. And those are the kinds of things, we can do, these ballot initiatives that the people start a grassroots campaign to, to get done and, and we saw it in Montana.
Crooked Con Election Integrity Part 1 - What A Day - Air Date 11-9-26
So we won the midterms. We did. It happened Okay. Regrettably, that does not change the makeup of the Department of Justice. Norm, how do we continue to fight voter suppression, voter oppression, and the actions of this Department of Justice with this Department of Justice?
I think we, do it the same way we have over the past 21 months. i- it's been, one of the historic, triumphs of American democracy and, of the, pro-voter civil rights, uh, movement really that lawyers have banded together. You have, the civil rights lawyers. You have the, state AGs.
you have the democracy groups, and, we have, absolute... they say, "Jane, when you meet a bear in the woods, you should make yourself bigger than the bear." So we banded together, as Vanita says, hundreds, thousands of us in the court of law, and won a series of cases, and we're gonna need to continue to do that, and carry it forward.
I count eight major election sabotage efforts by the Trump administration from their first executive order, which we working as a community, enjoined all the way to that last big win at the Supreme Court. That case was just dismissed last night by DOJ. They dropped their own case after they lost it at the Supreme Court.
So we'll just keep, we'll keep doing it. I do think that having Congress, on a pro-democracy footing and the ability of Congress now, they can also enter the fray legislatively. They can cut off funding. They can go to court themselves to enforce places where there wasn't standing. They can do investigations.
So, I'm optimistic that we're gonna be able to carry that pushback on DOJ forward. And then there's the criminal side. clients of mine like, Lisa Cook, the Fed governor, where we defeated that effort. Davey Hearn, the Reflecting Pool-
Right ...
defendant. We're gonna have to deal with those criminal, abuses as well, but I think we're up to it, and the judges have been superb.
The f- particularly the district court, the trial judges, they've been amazing, irrespective of who appointed them.
Where do you think the next fight is? You've been... you're talking about Mississippi, talking about Alaska, but moving forward Where are the ne- where is the next fight? Where, where do people in the pro-democracy movement need to be looking moving forward, even with a Democratic Congress?
I think we, we need to think about ways that we can hold the worst of the wrongdoers accountable for what they did. We know from, the history of backsliding democracies that you need to do, you need to have accountability for the worst wrongdoers, and then you need to have reconciliation for everyone else.
But no justice, no peace. If you don't have accountability for the ones who've, who've done these terrible things, you can't, you can't ever have that resolution.
Vanita because we could not stop winning, and I don't get tired of winning. this past week after the election for no apparent reason, Harmeet Dhillon stepped down- Mm, yep. ... from her efforts running the Civil Rights Department at DOJ, which regrettably I'm also putting in air quotes because what she seemed to do was, yell at people on the internet and make life worse for voters.
how do we revive the Civil Rights Department at DOJ after Trump? What, what does that look like? What does the division look like post-Dhillon and post-Trump?
So, it's interesting, and I think we should all keep our eye on who scurries out right now, whether it's-
There's a lot of scurrying
There's a lot of scurrying.
It's like rats leaving a sinking ship. Is it to avoid oversight? They can't avoid oversight because leaving the government actually doesn't allow you to avoid oversight. whatever the reason being, the pr- the issue is here is that I don't have much faith that her departure is going to change much for how the Civil Rights Division has been destroyed.
The Civil Rights Division now 80% of its lawyers, and these are the most incredible humans on the planet, have left the d- the Civil Rights Division because they were forced to. They were asked to do unethical things, whatever the reason, and it's not gonna be rebuilt during this administration. This is why elections matter, and the '28 election is going to be really, really important for basically the effort to rebuild the Justice Department.
And I've been working on a project with a lot of folks, a lot of incredible people, formers, from across administrations, but also a lot of smart people from the outside about how are we gonna rebuild this department that has been totally corrupted and corroded. There's ... The workforce has, has been completely disrespected.
Thousands of people have left, but also the department getting weaponized and conducting, which they will continue to do, which is what Norm's talking about. Stephen Miller is the Chief of Staff. He has been running the Justice Department for the last two years, and he is going to continue to do all kinds of things through the executive branch on immigration, which we know the whole thing on, Operation Metro Surge in Minneapolis, et cetera, was his brainchild.
We've gotta keep vigilant now. We've gotta be happy, and we have to celebrate, and we have to find the joy 'cause it is huge to have, a Senate and a, and a House of Representatives, hold a check on the executive branch. But we also cannot get complacent because the next two years, and this is, I think, what the pr- what Trump is trying to signal by choosing Stephen Miller, is that they're gonna continue to play a lot of these games.
But I ... The good news is, is that there's a lot of us already working To think about how we're gonna actually build, rebuild for '28, how we're gonna have both accountability and be able to deliver for the American people on the exactly what they need to fight corruption, to lower costs, et cetera. And so that's all part of the project forward, but we can't be, we can't become complacent right now.
And if I can add- Please, please ... well, we should talk about redistricting too, just really quickly.
Absolutely.
So, so part of what I think a lot of us, and I, I need to give Leah so much credit for all the organizing that Indivisible has done in communities across the country, and we need to stay organized, was remember mid-cycle redistricting, right?
people are pretty pissed about having their votes taken, or, having politicians choose their voters rather than voters choosing their politicians. Despite the fact that we had incredible turnout in the Deep South, uh, and, and saw the turnout be what it is, where Latino voters overcame a, a moral racial gerrymander in Texas, where we saw Black, the levels of Black voter participation across the South break records, historic records.
we also know that Mississippi, Tennessee, Alabama, Louisiana, South Carolina are getting ready in January to basically draw new maps again, and Texas is gonna maybe try to do it- ... in the lame duck to undermine Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa. So we need to stay very organized because it's the people power that all of you represent that did, led the pushback, and we've gotta keep that energy up to, to keep our eye on that ball.
The BONUS Win of Democrats' Blue Tsunami - No Lie with Brian Tyler Cohen - Air Date 11-4-26
on Tuesday, Democrats obviously taking the House and the Senate rightfully got the most attention, but something else happened that's gonna have major implications.
Democrats got trifectas in Arizona, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan, and Nevada. So with that in mind, let's talk about the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. First of all, what is it? It's an agreement among states wherein each state that joins promises to award all of its electoral votes to whichever presidential ticket wins the popular vote.
The deal only takes effect once the states that have signed on hold two-hundred and seventy electoral votes, which is a majority of the electoral college. Until then, nothing changes. And no constitutional amendment is required because the Constitution lets each state decide how to award its own electors.
The truth is that during a presidential election, only, seven states really matter. Candidates spend all of their time bouncing between those states and ignoring everybody else. And in some instances, like in 2000 and 2016, the person who got the most votes lost the presidency. That feels crazy for a country that calls itself a democracy.
It is not ridiculous to feel like the person who gets the most votes should also get the job. So here is the interesting part. So far eighteen states, along with Washington, D.C., have already joined, holding two-hundred and twenty-two electoral votes. Virginia was the newest. They signed on in April. That's forty-eight votes short of two-seventy.
But on Tuesday, Democrats won trifectas in Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. That means control of the governor's office and both chambers of the legislature. That's what a trifecta is.
Pennsylvania with nineteen electoral votes, Michigan with fifteen, Arizona with eleven, Wisconsin has ten, Nevada has six. Add those up and you get sixty-one. Two-hundred and twenty-two plus sixty-one is two-eighty-three. That is over the two-hundred and seventy threshold, meaning this election has officially put the interstate compact within reach.
Now, new legislatures don't get sworn in until January. Even if all five do it, two eighty-three is a thin margin. One state backing out later or the census redrawing the map in twenty thirty, that could put the compact back under two seventy. And of course, opponents are gonna challenge it in court. some are gonna argue that it hurts smaller states, which is all to say nothing is automatic.
But to that I say this: look at what Trump has gotten done. Say what you want about it, but he wanted a ballroom, so he demolished the East Wing of the White House and built one. Wanted a helipad, he built it. Wanted a golden-crusted Oval Office, he got it. Wanted banners of his own face on federal buildings, they went up.
He wanted his reflecting pool, so he did it. He wanted it, he made it happen. For a ballroom, a helipad, his own face, all absurd and ridiculous, absolutely. But the point is that he stopped at nothing to do it. He proved that the institutions that always trip up the Democrats are not sacrosanct. Now, he proved it for selfish reasons and vanity reasons and ego reasons.
We can do it for something virtuous. We can do it to deliver for regular Americans. The voters handed Democrats power. The question now isn't whether we deserve it, it's whether we opt to use it. And the lesson, the one lesson I'd want every Democrat in every one of these legislatures to take from this last year, is that power is for getting things done.
Now, here's the promise I'm gonna make to you. I will be like a fly on shit on this issue. I will not settle for the preservation of the status quo. If we wanna be the shining city on a hill, then we have to start acting like it. And it starts with adopting the principle that one person has one vote in this country, and that every vote counts the same.
You don't get more of a vote because you live in Arizona than somebody who lives in California. I will have every single one of these governors on my show, and I will press them on this issue. But we have an opening, and I don't wanna waste it. And for everybody watching and listening, if you live in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Nevada, or Arizona, call your state legislators.
Call your governor. Make them put this on the first week's agenda, not the last. Tell them that you didn't send them to Harrisburg or Lansing or Madison or Carson City or Phoenix to do nothing. And if you don't live in one of those states, find someone who does and send them this. We have the votes. We have the moment.
We have the momentum. For once, let's act like it.
We've just heard clips starting with
The PBS NewsHour compiling election-night remarks from victorious Democrats who promised to govern for working people, framing their wins as proof that money and the politics of division couldn't beat voters.
Democracy Now! reporting before the election was finalized that Democrat Scott Colom was leading in Mississippi's Senate race, and discussed the possibility of the state's first Black senator since Reconstruction.
More Perfect Union credited Democrats' midterm wins to candidates who ran on affordability and class-based issues, took on billionaires like Elon Musk, and channeled working-class anger into concrete agendas.
Stress Test celebrated the collapse of Trump's mid-decade gerrymandering strategy, where Republicans aimed for 15 new seats and may instead lose ground after Democrats redrew California.
Why, America with Leeja Miller pushed Democrats to pass popular legislation and force Trump to veto it on the record, building a vision rather than using his threatened vetoes as an excuse to do nothing.
The Daily Beans recounted how Elon Musk outspent his 2024 totals this cycle yet backed losing candidates, as Texas campaigns like Talarico's turned billionaire spending into a liability.
What A Day laid out how a Democratic Congress can now check the Justice Department under Trump through funding cuts, investigations, and lawsuits, and warned against complacency.
And No Lie with Brian Tyler Cohen made the case that the national popular vote agreement is now within reach, calling on Democrats to wield power boldly for democracy the way their opponents do for themselves.
And those were just the top takes, there's lots more in the deeper dives sections,
Remember, we can only make this show with your support and that includes following us on all the platforms you use. Check out our link in bio right in the show notes for every place to follow us and every way to support us, including one-time donations.
If you get value out of the show - and want to make sure we can keep going while getting it delivered ad-free to the new, members-only podcast feed that you'll receive, sign up to support the show at bestoftheleft.com/support - there's a link in the show notes - through our Patreon page, or from right inside the Apple Podcasts app.
I sometimes ask a discussion question in each episode to kick things off.
I asked in a previous episode whether your impression of wealth inequality had ever dramatically shifted. Here's a voice message we received.
Hey Jay and the best of the left team, it's Truman. I'm leaving this voice message in response to your episode Extreme Wealth is a WMD, specifically your voicemail prompt about wealth inequality. Like you, Jay, I don't think I ever needed to be convinced that wealth inequality is a bad thing or that it's something that needs to be addressed, but I think I always treated it as a secondary issue, at least until I started to realize, thanks in part to your show, that the wealth divide in this country is directly related to the power divide. I think the biggest revelation for me was that money is power and that that power is a corrupting influence that prevents us from achieving any real progress. And I think that's been more eye-opening for me than any graphic about how many yachts Jeff Bezos is worth ever could be.
And I think that feeds into another thought I've been having recently about the nature of being spoiled versus being entitled. We can imagine a spoiled billionaire as being someone who has all this wealth, has all this privilege, luxury, attention, but to some extent they acknowledge it. To some extent they might even be appreciative, but that's so much different than an entitled billionaire, which I think is the growing number of them, who they have all the same attributes of being spoiled, but they're not appreciative. They don't acknowledge their privilege. They think there's something inherent about them that means they deserve it, and they think they deserve more. We all might laugh at a spoiled billionaire who complains about his private jet being down for maintenance so he has to take a commercial flight, fly first class or something, right? It's funny. We laugh. But that's so much different than an entitled billionaire who thinks he gets to avoid our laws, he gets to avoid our regulations, doesn't have to pay taxes. And he also thinks he deserves to control our taxes and control our government. He thinks he is owed our attention, owed our admiration. Elon Musk is their poster boy. It's obvious how much he wants to be liked. It's pathetic. And he also thinks he deserves to have control over our government, control over our tax dollars, control over our politicians. That's why he spends hundreds of millions of dollars openly to try to buy elections.
And I think this is reminiscent of the same entitled power and wealth that the founders of this country rebelled against. And I think that is still in our blood. We laugh at spoiled billionaires, but entitled billionaires are more obvious. It's more obvious how unjust their wealth and power is. It's more obvious that they don't deserve it. And I think as more and more billionaires like Elon Musk make that obvious, more and more people will come out to oppose them, demand that we tax them, etc. That's just a hopeful thought I have, I guess. Thanks for all that you do. Bye.
And one more, a written comment from Christopher on Facebook, responding to our recent episode on Zionism and its Jewish critics. He writes,
"When I was a young teenager, well over a half century ago, I developed a rock-solid anti-Zionist world view. While I was raised in a Christian household, ethnically, my father was Jewish. I was keenly aware that most of our family that had remained in the old country had not survived the nightmare of Hitler. In my youthful attempt to make sense of that which is beyond all sense, I really tried to understand how otherwise good and decent people could have wholeheartedly supported the fascist regime, lived downwind of the crematoriums, or in full view of the camps, or the ghettos, or the trains, and been good with the sensory input. From my vantage point in America, 30 years after the fact, the reality of the nightmare seemed like it should have been impossible. Yet...
I read a great deal about how the fascists dehumanized the Jews, and the Gypsies, gays, and anyone else deemed unworthy of HUMAN consideration. Once so dehumanized, horrors that are still the stuff of nightmares became quite possible.
When I heard that same dehumanizing language in what the Zionists were saying about Arabs in general and Palestinians in particular... yeah, I became an anti-Zionist before I could drive. On a fundamental level, I believed it was, and is, impossible to be pro-Jewish and a Zionist. Unless, that is, one believes that drinking poison is an effective way to combat evil in the world..."
Thanks for those comments Christopher, very enlightening. It highlights how there really was always another way of thinking. The anti-Arab propaganda has been extremely strong, but it was always something that a person could see through and understand the destructiveness of if it were allowed to run its course.
And between these two comments, I think we're really getting to the heart of a lot of what people are demanding from the newly empowered Democrats. Things that were possible to ignore or excuse before are becoming impossible to ignore or excuse, and that means it's time for a fundamentally different approach.
The era of the argument that taxing the wealthy is a punishment for success is over. That idea was always nonsense, but I think it carried more weight back before people understood as clearly as they do now that the wealthy are corrupting our system and hoarding wealth that is being siphoned up from the rest of us.
And the bipartisan consensus that Israel deserved the United States to be its ride-or-die ally was a lot more plausible before people started seeing on their social media feeds what results we were buying with our billions of dollars of military aid.
It's too obvious now. It's too in your face, so even those who weren't generally tuned in before or accepted the premise that it was too complicated to understand have come around.
It is the nature of politicians to have their beliefs and convictions follow rather than lead those of their constituents. It is time for people in office to either evolve on the issue of Israel and billionaires, just as Obama claimed to evolve on the topic of marriage equality, or it's time for new candidates. Anyone who continues to adhere to the old status quo in an age of change may succeed in mildly delaying the shift but will ultimately be rolled over one way or the other.
Now, here's today's question:
How are your post-election vibes going among your left-leaning family and friends? How was your election night, how has the intervening time been, and how are y'all feeling now?
I'm not a super excitable person by nature. After the election, I saw videos of people jumping and screaming in their living rooms, and that was never going to be me, but we had an enjoyable election night. I was pleasantly surprised by the results, and there was only one moment of tension when we realized that there was a divide in the room on the topic of how far to go down the accountability path.
In the day or two after the election, I saw comments from people who were frustrated that they weren't being allowed to bask in their good vibes because some commentators had pivoted too quickly to criticism and difficult next steps.
I will say that it was as the results were coming in that I was looking at the math for the future of attempting to implement the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. So, I guess I would say there was a seamless blend between the positive feelings and a quick shift toward the work that comes next.
I guess I'm just glad that it's not my job to always try to be the first to comment on the news. I could have easily been someone's cause for frustration for not holding off on next steps long enough.
So, how have the vibes been with you and yours? Celebratory? Anxious to get it to work? Already dour about inevitable disappointment? How are you feeling?
If you'd like to share your thoughts, there's a link to leave a voice message in the show notes, or connect with us on socials or by email. All details are in the link in bio in the show notes.
As for today's topic,
Bernie Sanders didn't waste a minute to come out swinging. He said, two days after the election, in response to Chris Hayes talking about how the expectation should be for Trump to veto everything, that he wasn't so sure. Don't assume a veto, particularly on Medicare for All.
The more I think about it, the more that makes sense, and the less crazy it sounds. About a week later, Abdul El-Sayed, Michigan's new senator-elect, mocked up a gold TrumpCare card and put it on Twitter, inviting Trump to imagine that being on the table for him.
As a pragmatist, I genuinely don't care which president ultimately signs Medicare for All into law. If it carried Trump's name and legacy while paying for some surgery or cancer treatment or experimental medicine that helps keep me alive later, I wouldn't be cursing his name about it.
The thing that made Bernie's comment start to make even more sense is that Trump is a flip-floppy chameleon who goes with the breeze, and on top of that, supporting universal health care is actually one of his longest-stated preferences. He always hedges it by saying that it's kind of not possible, but at the same time says that it works elsewhere and that it's important for every American to be covered and for the government to pay for it. It's classic trial ballooning.
He's never been able to get traction within his own party because, of course, he can't, but his actual instinct isn't that far off from what the American people need. Republicans are the last group to continue falling for the decades of propaganda against universal health care. It's not just Democrats. Independents are wildly in favor of the government stepping in to ensure that everyone's covered.
We know that Trump isn't capable of putting forward a plan himself. That's why he waited on Republicans to conjure up his fantasy of a replacement for the Affordable Care Act that would somehow be better but also be in line with the GOP's corporate-friendly agenda.
Obviously, that was never going to happen, but if the Democrats did it for him, the pressure for him to sign it would be enormous. My prediction is that him signing universal health care into law wouldn't be seen by the history books as him betraying conservatism. It would be seen as bringing his party back to its roots.
Richard Nixon put near-universal coverage on the table in 1974, and Teddy Roosevelt ran on insurance against sickness way back in 1912. Plus, it's been a truism for decades that "only Nixon could go to China," and maybe, in the same strange way, only Trump can sign Medicare for All. We know Trump isn't going to run again, even though he long fantasized about figuring out a way to scam a third term, but if the Constitution didn't stop him, the 2026 elections surely have. The Republican Party is ready to turn on him, and all he has left is his legacy, which is currently in tatters across the spectrum, as his unpopular economic policies and wars have turned even loyalists against him.
Taking a big swing, like giving everyone health care, is basically the only thing big enough to salvage his tattered legacy. If Democrats need to be the latest group to give him a little gold trophy and a pat on the head to make him feel good, and in exchange we all get health care, I would make that deal.
If it's halfway reasonable to imagine we could get Trump to sign it, the biggest hurdle is the Senate filibuster. Pro-democracy politics watchers have known for years that it's outlived its usefulness and should have been on the chopping block a long time ago. In 2025, Trump demanded that Republicans abolish the filibuster and warned that if they didn't, Democrats would. That's what I call a political opening.
And it's not the only one. Zooming out, the Trump years should be understood as Trump almost single-handedly moving the Overton window on what is possible in terms of activist government.
At the absolute core of our current political era, the debate is between the dying age of neoliberalism and what comes next. Neoliberalism screamed bloody murder at the idea of the government doing anything, leading us to be faced with the horrible, untenable, nearly universally reviled outcome that governing strategy has wrought on everyone. What lies ahead is actually what Trump has been pointing toward, even though he's done it in the worst possible way.
He has argued and acted in a way that says that government can do big things if it wants to, and we shouldn't be handcuffed by the legacy of the old way of thinking that has made so many dissatisfied. The country may almost universally agree that what Trump has done with that instinct has been terrible and stupid, but the takeaway should not be a return to the era of government doing nothing, but to take the instinct that government can and should do big things, put that power in the hands of people who will wield it thoughtfully, and build things that help the American people rather than feed the leader's ego.
So if the Democrats want to do something for people, and the major trade-off is that it requires placating Trump's ego with a gold-plated TrumpCare card, then that would be the closest thing to functioning American government that I've seen in the last 20 years.
Note that we've begun putting my commentaries on YouTube so if you find them insightful, check out our channel and share them! Link in the show notes.
And now, we'll continue to dive deeper on 4 topics today. First up;
Section A, The Congressional Mandate
Followed by Section B, Power in the States
Section C, Anatomy of the Wave
And Section D, Lessons and Warnings
Section A starts with listeners calling in to The Brian Lehrer Show about what they want the new Congress to do on day one. Then What A Day talks about ending the filibuster and passing bills even if Trump vetoes them, speaking with Leah Greenberg of Indivisible, former associate attorney general Vanita Gupta and Norm Eisen of Democracy Defenders. And finally, Why, America makes the case for starting with Supreme Court reform.
Democrats, What Do You Want the New Congress to Do on Day One - The Brian Lehrer Show - Air Date 11-9-26
What do you want them to do first with respect to anything? 212-433-WNYC. Just float something out there. You don't have to think about it. Just, just blink and what comes to mind. Bill one, if there was... I think there's already a plan for an H.R.1, whatever that's gonna be.
But if there was an H.R.1 according to you, to you, House bill, what would it do? What would it be? 212-433-WNYC433-9692, call or text. Here's one answer from New York Congresswoman elect Dari- Daria Liza Avila-Travaliera speaking, over the weekend at, a Congressional Progressive Caucus meeting for incoming members.
Here's what she said is at the top of her to-do list.
I'm here for the NYCHA resident in my district who has had to suffer the indignity of mold in her child's, bedroom. I'm here for the immigrant communities in my district who do not deserve to live with the fear of ICE in our communities. I'm here for the people who deserve to have a universal childcare, a child tax credit.
So child tax credit, there's one thing. Here's more from Daria Liza when she was on Bridget Bergin's, "Who's Running This Place?"
For me, it really comes down to are we gonna have strong leadership that is gonna really push for the things that working people across this country have been demanding for ages, whether that is abolishing ICE, Medicare for all, the John Lewis Voting Rights Act- Mm.
-making sure that we are, fighting for universal childcare, investing our tax dollars in our, in our babies here and not in bombs abroad.
On WNYC.Okay, pretend you've got the ear of the incoming members of Congress. Maybe you do in some of these cases. I know some of them listen to the show. what do you want them to do first? John in the East Village, you're on WNYC. Hi, John.
Hi. so tax above 25 million at, untaxed wealth at death and inheritance, the public option for healthcare, background checks on guns, no anonymous campaign doings, and most controversial, no, subsidies for fossil fuels or solar wind.
We're cheaper. We can do it.
John has thought about it, and it... I don't think he was reading from a list, but he had that rist- list in his head, right? Susan in Brooklyn, you're on WNYC. Hi, Susan.
Hello. I think they should restore Medicaid cuts and give the veterans back their support for mortgages.
Thank you very much, Susan in Brooklyn.
Anthony in the Bronx, what should they u- do first?
Hey, Brian. I think they should implement term limits for the Supreme Court.
Anthony, thank you. Betsy in Blairstown, you're on WNYC. Hi, Betsy. What should they do first?
I think that they-- it's time for the Democrats to put forward a straightforward and detailed plan for Medicare for all.
I believe that people have been dancing around this problem for my entire lifetime. We have a crisis in the United States. We don't have enough doctors. We don't have any equity in medical care, and it's time to decouple it from employment and just make sure that everyone in this country has access to affordable and reasonable healthcare.
Thank
you very- And they can do it if they, if they make Trump believe that it'll be part of his legacy.
Thank you so much, Betsy. Some texts that are coming in. Listener writes, "Reverse DOGE cuts." Another one, "Protect voting rights. Make AOC Speaker of the House." Another one, "Reach out to Republicans to ask them to be bipartisan for the good of everyone."
James in Princeton, you're on WNYC. Hi, James.
All right. My, my thing is, Elon Musk, who has the, using the power to turn an internet on and off, m- allowing a, a country to defend themselves or, or fight back their attackers. I don't think a businessman should have this power. He's a businessman for profit.
That seems to be a government thing. I would like them, to start to discuss and use eminent domain to say, "You can't have this anymore."
Yeah, and I know you're referring to what's been, I guess, pretty well reported now that he individually cut off, his company Starlink's service to Ukraine for a while, which they were using, to defend against incoming Russian bombs.
Yep, he could do that as an individual, and that's what you're talking about. Sally on the Upper West Side, you're on WNYC. Hi, Sally.
Raise the federal minimum hourly wage. That would show everybody that the Democrats were serious about attacking affordability issue.
Thank you very much. Some nice, some, some additional texts coming in.
Make DC a state. Add dental, vision, and hearing to Medicare. Eliminate the filibuster. We'll definitely talk, be talking about that one on the show 'cause there will be pressure in the Senate to do that. Another one, stop all bombing. Health help abroad. Daniel in the Bronx, you're on WNYC. Hi, Daniel.
Good morning, Brian.
I agree with everything that everyone else has said, but let C- Congress try to do something simple first, and nothing could be simpler than revising the tax code to make all income the same as far as it is taxed, so that wages, dividends, interest, capital gains will all be treated the same from a tax point of view.
Thank you very much. Edson in Manhattan, you're on WNYC. Hi, Edson.
Hey. Hi, Brian. Thanks for taking my call. as an immigrant, I think it would be imperative for the new Congress that is coming on January 3rd to tackle immigration. I think this is a big issue that the Democrats should, tackle that, right on as soon as they, they go to the Congress next year.
How?
Well, I think, my... m- my opinion's that if you, if you're living over, been living over here in the US for over 20 years, you have a job, you have family, kids who were born over here, I think they should make a easier for you to get, a pass, a green card.
Pass to citizenship.
Yeah.
The citizenship. I think that should be priority to the Democrat. That's my view.
Edson, thank you very much. Last one. Frederick in Princeton, you're on WNYC. Hi, Frederick.
Yes. Thank you, Brian. I want to say all those suggestions were very nice, but I'd like to go to the prima donna one, and that is that Trump and company need to be held accountable because if not, this guy has nine lives and he's probably on number seven.
So I don't trust him at all, and he might be down right now, but that's only gonna be for a minute because while we're all talking on the left, and I'm happy about that, the right is fi- figuring out what they're going to do, and that involves Donald Trump coming back.
Crooked Con Election Integrity Part 2 - What A Day - Air Date 11-9-26
well, No Kings is a coalition for- Yes
it is a large scale coalition of know that mobilizes for kind of collective pro-democracy inflection points. and we'll be, we'll be working with that broader coalition on what's next for that. But I will tell you for Indivisible, we are, we are full force, and I can tell you 'cause I got on a call with, 1,500 Indivisible leaders earlier this week, and, I was like, "Congratulations," and trying to, love on everybody, and everybody's like, "What's next?
What are we doing?" And I was like, "Oh my gosh, everyone, take, take a minute." and people understand that winning power is, the necessary precondition for doing things with that power, right? We actually have ach- we've got, we've broken out of this, immediate authoritarian free-fall window, and now we are into the period where- With Congress, with the House, with the Senate, you can actually advance an alternate vision.
You can hold accountable people for the wrongdoing, for the corruption, for the law-breaking that has been happening over the last two years, and you can also show what the act- what governance could be like. You can pass policies that actually advance a vision that meets people's needs. And those two things do not happen automatically, and they do not happen without a lot of continued pushing from the outside.
We know that, this kind of, forward fighting is a muscle that we have to get Democrats to use and build and develop over time. We got a bunch of new champions in, and we've also got a lot of people who are not necessarily... They didn't start from a place of fight forward, and we gotta get those folks in motion.
We need to under- have people understand that they work for us, and that we need to see results as a result of all the hard work that we have done to get them into office.
Do, do, do you wanna text Chuck Schumer directly or, should I, or...?
well, we, well, we actually are, we are calling on the leadership fight specifically.
We're calling for an open process. We're... It's not about any specific person. It's, and it's, it, we are, we sh- there should be no coronation of leadership, right? We should actually ha- the caucus should have a conversation about what is the strategy? What does fighting look like, right? We've laid out a set of condition- or a set of demands on the lame duck.
End the war. Claw back ICE funding. Use it to patch the Medicaid cuts ticking time bomb. Get rid of the filibuster now so that we can actually pass the bold legislation and force Donald Trump to veto it. This is the kind of agenda that, a, a Democratic Senate and Democratic House that are fighting forward could actually embrace if we move them to.
Something that I've been struck by, that is deeply heartening and I think may somehow not have gotten quite enough attention is this is the biggest Democratic victory of my lifetime. It's far bigger than 2006, and I think that why that is is because of the states. State legislatures, state gubernatorial wins, 75% of Americans now will live in a state with a Democratic governor.
Democrats have won trifectas across the country. shout-out to Wisconsin for those of us- Those of us who remember the fights of the early 2010s, it's, it's been a long time coming. But Vanita, what does that mean for state-level action? Because we've been talking obviously about the power of the federal government, but for m- millions of Americans, they have had their rights usurped by their own state houses.
What's next on that fight?
So, this statistic to me is almost one of the things that's the most hopeful because the amount of opportunity now that we have at the state level to get policies enacted that we all care about... And I will say for a lo- for the last several years, election denialists at the state level have been, like, getting into all these positions locally.
We've had states try to make voting harder, not easier, passing, all kinds of laws around cutting early voting, you know, trying to push voter ID, et cetera. We now have an opportunity, an unprecedented opportunity with this, with the fact that 75% of Americans are gonna be, w- with Democratic governors who wanna make v- voting more accessible, to actually lay infrastructure now to make permanent changes to how open our elections can be and to make sure that election denialists that have infected and infused at the local level are pushed out and that we can actually get pro-democracy people into these positions.
We cannot afford, and it's gonna require all of you and all of us pushing now and understanding where there's opportunities. All of these policies that Leah's been talking about, at the federal level, we need to actually seed at the state level. It's gonna help create an agenda as well for a day where we might possibly have, a, a pro-democracy trifecta in, in, in Congress.
So all of this stuff on healthcare, on, on, police not cooperating with ICE, on democracy efforts and m- making voting more accessible, we've got an opportunity now at the state level to lay the groundwork for a national agenda on all of these issues.
Norm, do you wanna-
further to Vanita's point, and in fact to pick up on, Leah's answer to your question, Jane, the...
I hope we will also move from playing defense, which has been so successful where we worked well at the federal and state level over the past 21 months, where we would talk to Congress, we would talk to state AGs, we would bring these cases, the, civil society sector, that we do the same on offense and that our, our leaders, whether they're governors, AGs, secretaries of state responsible for election, members of Congress, that they say, they look at this as an opportunity.
What was... This election was a referendum, number one, on corruption. That was the number one issue. How do we deal with corruption? How do we address the nexus between the number two issue, the cost of being alive, and the corruption tax that Trump and his cronies and many in big business, big media, and big tech have laid on us?
How do we address that and think of it as a three-year process? There's stuff we can do now. Next year is gonna be, '28 is gonna be another referendum. And then '29, can we consolidate power to really deliver for the American people? I hope we won't become the captives of the consultant class, of the traditional way of thinking-
of the lobbyists on our own side, that we'll fight the corruption ourselves, that we'll pass a stock trading ban by rule- ... the first day we're in Congress, and that we show the American people it's not gonna be business as usual. We are serious about ending the corruption, bringing your cost down. That's what democracy means to these Americans.
And can I,
I just,
I, the, I, I get, I get so excited about this 'cause I think right now for the next two years in Congress, yes, we need all the oversight and the accountability, but I want our members to be dropping bills every week that are about solving problems for the American people, and let President Trump veto them.
Let, let's flush out who is not for solving problems. Introduce a ban, a bill ending partisan gerrymandering, and let's see which members of our Congress are gonna refuse to sign that. But, lay the groundwork on all of these issues. Introduce smart bills, like, and don't waste time, so that you are showing the American people what you stand for and the fact that you are gonna be out there to solve problems, and there are, there are, uh, there are people out there that are gonna obstruct that.
Let's flush them out and name them, but at least we will all know how it is that people can solve problems, what we're demanding of our members of Congress. This is the chance to show, even if we know these bills may not get signed, let's m- let's, let's put it all together, make that agenda clear to the American people, and then we've got something that we stand for and that we can election, campaign on, too.
That's gonna be so important to offer Americans a vision of what this means.
A Historic Election (And What Comes Next) Part 2 - Why, America with Leeja Miller - Air Date 11-4-26
Here are the substantive policies I think they should push for. First and foremost, Supreme Court reform. Yes, I think that is the number one issue that needs addressing first.
In my most recent video about the Supreme Court, I made the argument that the Court's power to override the will of Congress and slap down federal laws as unconstitutional is not a power they should possess and is a power that Congress could take away from them. There's nothing in the Constitution that says the Supreme Court gets to say what is and isn't constitutional.
There is nothing democratic about nine unelected elites in robes being able to overrule the will of Congress, the body that most closely represents the will of the people. There are very few examples in history of the Supreme Court ever dismantling federal laws in ways that gave us more rights. Other than dismantling the Defense of Marriage Act and legalizing gay marriage across the land, which I'll give them that one, the Supreme Court for the past 250 years has mostly made rulings that got rid of civil rights protections passed democratically by Congress, or gutted protections put forward by Congress to keep money from influencing our elections, or undid voting protection laws or the Affordable Care Act.
Time and again, the Supreme Court has undone the will of the people, and there is nothing in the Constitution that says they're allowed to do that. The only thing that says they can is their own precedent,
But the point is that we first must wrench power out of the hands of the nine elites in robes that are holding the reins of Congress before we can make any substantive changes that are going to last. You do that by passing an enforceable code of ethics with an independent oversight body that has actual enforcement powers so the Supreme Court justices are forced to comply with a code of ethics that requires them to recuse themselves if there are conflicts of interest, for example, or bans immediate family members from being actively involved with trying to overthrow Congress, for example, or bans justices from accepting lavish vacations from people with vested interests in cases coming before the court, for example.
You bring the court to heel because democracy demands it, and then Congress must pass a law banning dark money and outside spending from attempting to influence the outcomes of our elections, banning corporations from donating money to influence our elections, and keeping caps in place for individual donors to election campaigns.
And in that law, in order to get around Citizens United, Congress must write that the US Supreme Court does not have the jurisdiction to hear cases as to the constitutionality of the law. There is nothing in the Constitution that says Congress can't pass a law that limits the Supreme Court's jurisdiction over the law's constitutionality.
Then and only then will we have a Congress that genuinely and fully represents the will of the people as it is supposed to do. Because right now, studies have shown that whether or not the people want a bill to pass has quite literally zero impact on whether the bill passes in Congress. But If the top 0.1% wants a bill to pass or not pass, they have the demonstrable ability to sway the outcome of bills.
That is not a pluralistic democracy at work, and until Congress answers to the will of all of the people equally, and people only, not corporations, there is no way to fix the broken system. We then need to provide a floor for everyone, not just the neediest, but everyone. That floor should include healthcare, affordable food, and affordable housing.
No one should be able to profit off the things humans need to sustain life. And to pay for it, we need to increase taxes on the wealthiest 1% of Americans. This includes closing loopholes around hoarding unrealized gains, using your stock portfolio to borrow gobs of cash, and passing your money onto your heirs in a way that keeps them from paying their fair share of inheritance taxes.
No one should go hungry and homeless in the richest country on Earth. They need to pass and enforce the Green New Deal or similar to ensure not only that Americans aren't reliant on fossil fuels half a world away, but also to ensure that Americans have a future that includes clean air and drinking water, and lessens the worst effects of climate change, which is only gonna continue to get worse, and to impact the essential things for life, like water and the global food supply chain.
The quickest win here would be some sort of moratorium on AI and data centers, which are already incredibly unpopular, and enforceable laws around responsible AI development, environmental standards for data centers, and protections for everyday Americans so their energy bills don't skyrocket when a data center moves in down the street.
And Trump could veto all of that, but they need to run on this vision to inspire people, and then get a Democrat into the White House in 2028 who can move forward with these initiatives, as well as reinstate my queen Lina Khan, or someone like her, as the head of the FTC so that antitrust laws, which are already on the books, by the way, Congress doesn't even have to do anything with this one, so that these laws are being enforced against the media conglomerates, the tech bros, the food conglomerates, and all the other bad actors that are engaging in anti-competitive behavior to the detriment of all of us.
Those few initiatives, Supreme Court reform, getting money out of politics, increasing taxes on the top 0.1%, initiating a social services program that provides food, shelter, and healthcare for every single American, protecting the environment, and ensuring that our antitrust laws are being enforced, would so materially improve the lives of every single American.
And these are not revolutionary suggestions. These are bare minimums that a lot of similar countries already recognize. People vote on vibes, not logic or reason or numbers, and they vote on the economy and how stable they personally feel financially. Pushing for those initiatives will actually improve lives and will also probably have the happy byproduct of winning progressive Democrats elections in the future, because the people will actually feel for the first time in decades that the people in charge of the Democratic Party actually give a shit about them.
Imagine that. So please bask in the glow of millennial hope core in this moment, but know that it is now on us to hold these people to the high standards that they should be meeting, and know that federal elections are just one piece of the puzzle. There's a lot happening at the local level that the federal government doesn't touch that's being meddled with by the same shitty actors that are also in the federal government.
There's a lot of fuckery and tomfoolery happening with abortion access, with trans rights bills, with gerrymandering, that often goes unnoticed because these major federal elections take up so much of our attention. So don't forget to keep it local and be in community for the continued fight ahead.
Next, Section B, Power in the States
First up, Baby Boom! Lawyered sizes up the real odds of electing presidents by national popular vote. The BradCast talks with Gaby Goldstein of State Futures about what new Democratic majorities can do fastest, and why the left trails the right in the states. Then Democracy Now! talks with Daniel Nichanian of Bolts about what the new Democratically-controlled state governments plan to do.
Can Democrats Really End the Electoral College? - Baby Boom! Lawyered - Air Date 11-10-26
I'm Imani Gandy, and on today's docket, people on social media are freaking out about the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. And honestly, people need to calm down The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which I'm going to refer to as the compact because who has the goddamn time, is a fun little mechanism that states can use to basically nullify the electoral college without having to go through the hassle of a constitutional amendment.
Because the electoral college is bullshit. A handful of battleground states are the ones where votes really matter, and everybody else gets told to go fuck themselves. So the notion of sidestepping the electoral college sends a tingle down my legs. But I'm gonna need people to slow their roll with headlines like, "America finally has the votes to end the electoral college."
Whoa, whoa, whoa. Getting more state lawmakers to enact the compact means a bunch of state lawmakers are going to need to find a spine they often have a hard time locating. In six states, Democrats nabbed trifecta control of the governor's office and both chambers of the legislature. That puts a national popular vote in play for 2028 if it can get passed and if it survives the Supreme Court, which, in case you haven't noticed, is a hot mess of suck and corruption.
Every state gets to decide how it hands out its electoral votes. The Constitution leaves that up to them. And almost every state picked winner take all. You win the state, you get the whole pile of electoral votes. Take Colorado where I live, 10 electoral votes. Colorado joined the compact in 2019. And Colorado voters said, "Yep, we're gonna keep it in 2020."
The compact is a promise. Once it kicks in, if a Democrat wins Colorado but a Republican wins the most votes nationwide, Colorado hands all 10 of its electoral votes to the Republican. Now, before you start screaming, that's just how it works. Every member state makes the same promise. And it cuts both ways.
And if your state never joins, your vote still goes into the national pile. Everybody's does. Now, quick history detour. When the founders were writing the Constitution, southern states wanted enslaved people counted toward their population so they'd get more seats in the House. They wanted every single person who was enslaved counted in full, people that they owned, people that they would never in a million years let vote.
They settled for three-fifths. Three-fifths still meant extra House seats for slave states built on people who had no say in anything. And a state's electoral votes come from its House seats plus its two senators. Those extra seats turned into extra electoral votes. Slaveholders got extra say in picking the president courtesy of the people they enslaved.
That is some evil ass math. And then it got worse. After the Civil War, the 14th Amendment threw out the three-fifths rule. It literally says to count, quote, "The whole number of persons." So almost four million people who had been enslaved now counted as whole persons, which great, I love Black people being whole people Then white Southerners used violence, fraud, poll taxes, and literacy tests to keep Black people from voting.
In other words, the South kept the extra seats and got rid of the voters. Basically, the Electoral College paid off for white Southern power twice. Once under slavery, and again under Jim Crow. Remember that the next time somebody starts dry humping the Framers and calling them geniuses. A bunch of states, plus DC, have signed on to this deal to hand their electoral votes to whoever wins the most votes nationwide.
The deal only switches on once the votes of the members add up to 270, a majority of the Electoral College, because a majority elects a president no matter what the rest of the country does. Right now, they're still a couple of big states short. Last week, Democrats won full control of state governments in Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Nevada.
I did the math, so take my word for it. If Pennsylvania and Michigan sign on to the compact, then the compact needs just two more states from the remaining three, Wisconsin, Arizona, Nevada. Any two of them get the compact over the line. Without Pennsylvania and Michigan, the math sort of falls apart. But the state legislatures don't have forever to decide whether or not to join the compact.
The compact has to be in effect by July 20th, 2028. Miss that date, and the 2028 election runs on the old rules, no matter how many states have signed on to the compact. So the honest headline is that Democrats won enough state houses to put a national popular vote within reach for 2028. Within reach. At least four of those legislatures actually have to sign on for it.
A trifecta in a state legislature means a shot at passing the bill. But Democrats have had this exact shot before and weren't able to deliver. Take Nevada for instance. In 2019, the Democratic legislature passed it, and the Democratic governor, Steve Sisolak, vetoed it. What the fuck, Steve? In fairness, he said it could shrink the clout of small states like Nevada, and honestly, that is a real problem.
The states the compact is counting on to get to 270 are all swing states. Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Nevada, Arizona. And swing states get pampered. And it's more than just attention. Political scientists Douglas Criner and Andrew Reeves found that presidents funnel more federal grant money into swing states.
So if you're a Pennsylvania state lawmaker, voting for the compact means voting to put all that attention and money at risk. Try explaining that one at the Bucks County Fair. Signing on to the compact was no big deal when the compact was a pipe dream, when it was nowhere near 270. Being the state that actually flips the whole thing on is a different level of scary say they're able to pull it all off. Enough states sign on to get to 270 electoral votes. Welp, that's when the lawsuits start getting filed. The compact leaves the electoral college standing.
States still pick electors, and those electors still cast the official votes for president. The only change is which candidate a member state's electors vote for. They go to whoever won the whole country. Supporters of the compact point to Article Two of the Constitution, which lets each state legislature decide how its electors get chosen.
Opponents of the compact point to the Compact Clause in the Constitution, which says states can't make deals with each other without Congress's permission. The Court has read the Compact Clause pretty narrowly, mostly requiring Congress to sign off when a deal grabs power from the federal government.
Now, opponents say a deal that picks the president is exactly that kind of deal, which is not a crazy argument. I'll give 'em that. No court has ever ruled on this, and even the compact's own people expect to get sued the second the compact hits 270 electoral votes. Which means this whole thing ends up in front of the same Supreme Court that has spent 13 years shivving the Voting Rights Act in the kidney.
I would not bet the house on those jamokes. What Democrats won last week is the best shot this thing has had in 20 years. Now, realistically, Pennsylvania and Michigan, plus at least two of Wisconsin, Nevada, and Arizona have to actually pass it, and then somebody has to defend it in front of the Supreme Court.
Lord help us.
How Dems Must Use the 'Tectonic Shift of Power' at the State Level; Guest Gaby Goldstein of State Futures Part 1 - The Bradcast - Air Date 11-11-26
you argue, that, that governing in the states then is really where lawmakers can actually improve lives for Americans most immediately, most directly, and as they have to do it quickly. A lot of these states, don't even have full-time legislatures. They are just maybe, i- i- in office for a number of, of months and need to get it done.
Though there was a time, I think I'm even old enough to remember it, I think, when state lawmakers actually worked together to compromise, to adopt legislation at the state level. they, where they might have to w- give a little something, to Democrats or give a little something to, to Republicans.
giving up something in each case. But they found compromise necessary to move things forward. Maybe I'm just romanticizing the, the, the past here, but now it kinda seems like real change only seems to happen for good or ill, by the way, when, when parties are able to win legislative trifectas in, in the states, control of, both the governor's mansion and both chambers of, of the legislature.
Am I romanticizing the past, or has that always been the case, or have things changed, in, in recent decades in that regard?
I think that I, I am very optimistic about what states that do not have full Democratic trifectas can get done, right? you look at a state like Georgia, where now Democrats control, control one chamber and the governor's mansion, right?
Mm-hmm. you're really close. North Carolina, so, so many states, that are now on that board. And one thing that I always come back to is I did a lot of work on the political side in Virginia back in 2017- Mm-hmm ... which was the first, first set of statewide races after, the, the first Trump election.
groundswell of momentum, enthusiasm. Democrats came, it came down to a tie for the, the House of Delegates, the lower chamber. Mm-hmm. It actually came down to a tie, and the way that Virginia, manages a tie is to pull a name out of... Put two names into a ceramic bowl in, a film canisters- Mm-hmm ... and see whose name comes out, and it turned out that it was not Shelly Simon's, the Democrat's name.
So Republicans, it maintained very slim control. but th- Ralph Northam, was elected governor that year. Mm-hmm. Democrat Ralph, Ralph Northam, and that legislature went on to pass Medicaid expansion. Mm-hmm. Even though Democrats did not have a trifecta, but because Democrats- Had so much more power in bo- in that, in that lower chamber- Yeah
in the governor's hou- in the governor's mansion. They were able to, to put some things together and get a few Republicans to cross the line. and so you look at states like Georgia, when you think about Medicaid expansion and what could be coming next, right? So, I... Listen, having a Democratic trifecta is great.
You, you, certainly you can... And, and honestly, there are now, nine states that gained Democratic supermajorities- Mm-hmm ... in, in at least one of their chambers, and that's even better, right? that's even sweeter. Like Colorado, for instance, has a veto-proof supermajority. They don't even need Phil Weiser's, Mm-hmm
uh, pen, pen on the line for their bills. But, but sh- certainly that makes governing, the... it expands the aperture of what you can get done- Mm-hmm ... in, in terms of governing. But I do not at all feel that the states that got close and that have a huge amount of power that they didn't use to have, that, you know, that there's nothing that they can get accomplished.
I absolutely believe there'll be, there'll be deals to get done, and the reason why is the extremis that everyday Americans are, are in, right? these are... when you look at med- the Medicaid cuts that are coming in January, when you look at the, the, 100 million, Americans saddled with, with medical debt, these sorts of, issues that are so, profound and, and, frankly put a ton of fiscal pressure on states, I think that we're gonna see a lot more get done, even in states that don't have, those trifectas, just because of, frankly, the fiscal emergency that states are in- Mm-hmm
uh, and the, the absolute need. And folks m- may or may not know, but states are not a- generally allowed to carry a deficit. Right. It's in the state, it's in their state constitutions. They just can't carry a deficit. And so, that forces peop- that forces legislators to the table in these sorts of fiscal emergencies in a way that, doesn't happen at the federal level.
Your, piece at, Talking Points Memo cites a bunch of, a bunch of stuff and a bunch of states, some of it really long overdue, that you expect to or would like to see happen, now that Democrats have won, in some of these states governing trifectas, in, in some key states, including all of the critical, so-called blue wall states like Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota.
as we're, will soon enough be heading into a presidential election, so those states are gonna be key again. Can you walk me through, just some of those, possibilities that you, you detailed at TPM that, the ones that come to mind for you? I'll, I'll, of course, I'll link to your piece where you cite a lot of them, but what jumps out at you as stuff that can now finally happen in some of the states where Democrats won, as you de- described it, truly tectonic shifts last week
Yeah, one that just pops out off, just like it's like a glaring red beacon in the night Mm-hmm
is the fact that Pennsylvania and Wisconsin still have $7.25 minimum wage. Mm. and that is just, astonishing- Mm-hmm ... and, certainly far out of step with now what their similarly situated trifecta states have done, right? With, with, with basically everyone else at a $15 minimum wage, or- Mm
at least on a path to that. So there's some, there's some, policies like raising the minimum wage that are just, those sort of glaring red flags - Yeah ... for certain states, which I'm sure will be, on, on the table and, and in discussion immediately. we f- we do a lot of work in, in labor policy and in health- healthcare access and, and, and delivery policy an- and so, there are so many, opportunities, just tremendous opportunities for these trifectas to catch up, one could say, or at least, come into line with their s- their peer states.
Mm. so you know, some of those that we're watching are, keeping medical debt off credit reports. There are 15 states that, that, that prohibit medical debt from ending up on your credit report- Mm ... which of course has a huge impa- i- impact on people's abilities to get a lease- Mm-hmm ... to get a job, right?
And so, five of these six new trifectas have the opportunity to, to, to get that done. Mm. There, there, there are lots and lots on labor and healthcare, lots of ways for states to, to tackle, the immediate challenges that folks are facing. And so minimum, everything from minimum wage to med- we talked about Medicaid expansion.
Yeah. that is really on the table for some of these states that have been, latecomers, one could say. and these really are the issues that, that affect our daily lives. driving down the cost of prescription drugs. There's so much that states can do around capping insulin at $25 as many, $25 a month as, many states have, particularly Democratic trifecta states.
and the other that I'd say that we do a lot of work around is federal response or frankly, how to hold this federal administration to account for the illegal activity, and, and constitutional violations, that federal agents have been inflicting on people and communities. Mm-hmm. And states have a lot of opportunity to hold immigration, agents, liable at the state level for, for violations of civil rights, as well as to bar immigration enforcement at place, at sensitive locations like schools and clinics.
Lots of states have done that already, Democratic trifectas, and now there's just a lot more states that, that can, can, can, you know- Yeah ... really pursue those policies and, and find ways to hold, again laddering up to 28, find ways to hold this administration to account even at the state level, beyond just the oversight, hearings and subpoenas and all the rest at, at, in, in DC, but actually get that work done at the state level too.
The Country Says 'No' to Trump: Not Just Congress, the Blue Tsunami Flips Statehouses Across U.S. - Democracy Now! - Air Date 11-5-26
so what is your sense at the state and local level? What were voters, most interested in?
What made them vote Democrat this time? Well, it's, it's, similar reasons as we saw, at the federal level, the cost of living. Democrats in Texas and Ohio and many states were really emphasizing the issue of the, data centers, immigration enforcement, and those are all issues where we're gonna see... now that Democrats took more power in state governments, we're, we're gonna see actual potential changes being done, at a level of government where, that has a lot of effects on, on these, on, on these issues. So for instance, the, the Democrats took control of, of six state governments on Tuesday, perhaps seven if Alaska flips.
We are still waiting for, for results there in the governor's race. so we're talking about, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Arizona, Michigan, Minnesota, and Nevada. Those all are states that became, Democratic now. And, and some of these states have Democrats haven't governed for a very long time, and they, and they've signaled the kind of agenda they want to bring.
So for instance, in Pennsylvania, which Democrats haven't governed, since the n- '90s, they've signaled they want to codify abortion rights into the state constitution. In Wisconsin, where Democrats haven't governed since 2010, they have signaled they wanna re- repeal, abolish the anti-union law that, that Scott Walker very famously, and it drew a lot of protests nationwide and in Wisconsin, passed in 20- 2011.
So in a, in a way, there's a lot of issues that have b- built up, up, up until Tuesday. And Daniel, you've also said, let's talk about the places where the Democrats didn't prevail, or at least don't have, won't have full control. Georgia, North Carolina, you say is also because of gerrymandering, Republican gerrymandering, if you could explain.
Right. it's the story you may have heard out there over the past few days that gerrymandering failed for Republicans in the US House. They were trying to gerrymander their way to a majority. That didn't succeed. The, the situation is more nuanced if you look at the state level. Ge- Georgia and North Carolina are two states that saw huge tsunamis on Tuesday.
The statewide offices, flipped. The, the size of the wins for Democrats in statewide races was w- wild. u- unthinkable even. And yet, and yet, Democrats didn't manage to win control of the state government. Why? Because the state senate in both states is so aggressively ge- ge- gerrymandered that Democrats just couldn't get over the hurdle.
In, in North Ca- Carolina for instance, Democrats are one seat short of getting full control of the state government despite the gerrymander. They won every seat that Trump won by up to 10, 10, 10 points. Any seat that Trump won by less than 10, flipped Democrats, and that wasn't enough because the median seat in North Carolina has been so gerrymandered, it's so Republican, so that allowed Republican to keep a, a foothold of power in states where by all accounts they, they, they, they, they, they really should have lost everything on, on Tuesday.
So D- Daniel Nishanian, let's talk about what states can do, all over the country, the significance of states having power. you have the irony that with President Trump, and with the Republicans, they're often talking about states' rights, but then they try to federalize everything from the election to law enforcement.
so if you can talk about, oh, states passing laws that ban local police and local sheriffs from collaborating with ICE, for example. Where can states assert themselves? that, that's really important, and it's gonna be a major storyline looking f- looking ahead to 2027 on, on many of the issues that people look toward DC.
states have a lot of power. That's a great example. The, the issue of immigration, which was a driving, driving factor for many voters, the opposition to, to Trump's immigration, policies, and ICE over the last year and a half. what we have seen actually since Trump came into power in 2025, came back into power, is a wave of, of states, of blue, blue states, of Democratic-governed states that have passed laws that have banned lo- local police and local sheriffs from entering co- contracts with ICE.
Now, that actually does ... is very important because ICE really relies on the collaboration of local sheriff, agencies and police to e- expand its reach. For instance, for instance, sh- sheriffs can rent space, in their jails to ICE to hold immigrants. ICE can bring immigrants there, pay, pay money to the sheriff's department.
By the way, it also puts mo- more money into lo- local law enforcement through that route, and, and that, that helps ICE do it- do, do its operations. and, so ni- nine states, nine, nine de- dem- Democratic-run states since the beginning of 2025 have banned these, these sort of contracts. States like Vi- Vir- Vir- Virginia, New, New Mexico, Ma- Ma- Maryland have passed laws like that.
Now, the obvious question, I was listing earlier the list of states that Democrats have flipped. Are we gonna see similar laws in Pennsylvania, in Wisconsin, in Arizona? These are all states where lo- local sheriffs, there are some very, f- far right sheriffs in those states that have contracts with ICE.
Are Democrats at the state level gonna do something about it? So that's just an example of the kind of questions that this really opens up, and you could do that, that on issue after issue. What are Democrats gonna do with the, with, with, with, with the new authority they're gonna have in these states?
And if you could speak, Daniel, spec- spec- specifically about, unions, the states that have had extremely restrictive, laws on unions. if you could just talk, for example, about Wisconsin or Nevada. Right. another, another issue where Democrats, have not as systematically, done recently, the, the politics around union, unions having shifted a bit.
But, Nevada, Wisconsin are, and others are states that have either passed a, a right to work law or, in Wisconsin as I was, as I was saying earlier, it was really the, the... It was really one of the main issues when Republicans took power after the 2010 midterms. They went after, unions in Wisconsin and other states.
and Democrats, Democrats wanna, wanna ro- ro- ro- roll that back. And, and we'll see. also there was a, an important, referendum in Ve- Vermont on Tuesday that enshrined the right to join a union into the const- the Constitution of the, of the State of Vermont. and that also passed, on Tuesday, so another, im- important result.
How Dems Must Use the 'Tectonic Shift of Power' at the State Level; Guest Gaby Goldstein of State Futures Part 2 - The Bradcast - Air Date 11-11-26
Gaby Goldstein, you argue that, quote, "New trifectas will face plenty of competing demands and enormous room to improve lives quickly." You listed just now some of the many competing demands that have, uh, piled up in some of these states.
And critically you argue they can do it together. "Conservatives," you explain, "figured this out long ago. ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council, has spent half a century moving model bills from capital to capital, and when 22 Republican state financial officers want to lean on Wall Street, they sign one single letter.
The center-left," you write, "has been slow to build that kind of state power infrastructure. We're building it now," you say, "through shared policy, cross-state learning, coordinated action, and interstate compacts that let states pool their power." Now, I suspect, Gabby, that a lot of our f- folks in our l- our audience are likely to recoil when they hear the, comparison to ALEC, the, very well-funded right-wing group that has written and fed model legislation to Republicans in state legislatures for years.
How is what your group is doing, different and/or similar in that regard to ALEC?
Yeah. I'm so glad that your, that your readers and listeners are familiar with ALEC. Not nearly enough Americans are familiar with ALEC. Mm-hmm. It is an organization that has had such a, fin- fingers in many policy pies that- Mm-hmm
you know, one of the things that the Right really understood early was that by moving state policy, you could move national policy. Mm-hmm. And so they have had a very successful strategy around doing exactly that for, the, the last half century. But I think that one thing that is really interesting about ALEC is that it was started as a reaction to what the Right thought the Left was doing well.
Mm-hmm. Particularly around labor organizing. Mm-hmm. at state level, labor federations. And, Paul Weyrich and, and, and crew looked at that and said, "We want that for the Right." So I always find that kind of an, a, an interesting- Mm-hmm ... irony, that ALEC was actually... The motivation for, for starting ALEC was what they thought we were doing well.
I, whether we really-
The response, the response to the so well-organized Left-
Yeah. Right ... that has never
been organized at all. Okay.
Yeah. No, that is exactly my point, right? Yeah, yeah. And it's like the irony is, crushing. It's like crushing. But, but the thing I would say about ALEC, I, I... And I've said this, I've said this before.
I think that the Left misjudges ALEC as just a, an evil bill mill, and they're just, s- churning out the slop and, passing it around. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. certainly I don't agree with a single thing- You know, from a policy perspective that ALEC has ever done. But ALEC is, in fact, an organizing operation.
Mm-hmm. They are really organizing real people- Yeah ... real legislators who share values in a community over time, building relationships, and moving policy through a trust network. That is, that, that needs to be acknowledged, and I don't think it's... I think we gloss over that- Yeah ... on the left. and hey, we're supposed to be the side of organizing, right?
we're supposed to, be the organizers, but ALEC is an organizing operation in, in a significant way. Um, and so I definitely, I'm not, Our, our, our organization is not, templated on ALEC or anything, but we certainly... I, I consider myself an organizer as well. Yeah. And certainly a lot of what we're doing is organizing and mobilizing the, the lawmakers who share our values around the issues that they care about and that they're working on.
and certainly ALEC's, working group model has been a really successful model- Yeah ... where they have, certain, working groups. And of course, it is an evil, evil cabal of you know- Yeah ... big oil at the table with these, Republican lawmakers. So, i- in that sense, we bear no resemblance whatsoever.
We're different species, entirely. But getting working groups of lawmakers together to meet over time and, collaborate on policies and priorities is what we do as well and, I think is a really important, again, organizing model. Yeah. So, I think that ALEC, part of ALEC's success has been its ability to pre- create a forum and a community for like-minded policymakers, to, to work together, and certainly that's what we're doing too.
Although, again, I, I never... Couldn't possibly find a single ALEC, bill that I could agree with, I'm sure, out of the hundreds and many hundreds that they've-
Yeah ...
churned out over the decades.
Yeah. I... And obviously, they are clearly powered and funded by right-wing interests, corpor- huge corporate interests.
Huge. in, in truth, I don't think, anyway, there's anything unlawful about what ALEC has been doing for so many years, despite how much, they are loathed on the left. And, frankly, as you note, they have been quite effective at it, and I've l- l- long wondered If what the left really hates the most about ALEC is the fact that they are effective, and the fact that, there has really been no equivalent organizations, it seems to me, on the left.
And, like the, the left is mad because they didn't think of this idea first, frankly. is, is, is, is that a fair assessment?
Well, I think it's a little more nuanced. What I would say is that on the left, we have done a couple of things very differently than the right. On the left, we have never invested in state-level infrastructure.
We have over-invested, generationally over-invested, in my view- Mm-hmm ... in federal advocacy- Hmm ... federal, candidates, fe- the- Mm-hmm ... federal government, right? and there's reasons for that, right? we, on the left, we've, we have a very complicated relationship to state-level power. It goes back to the founding of the country, right?
And, a group of people... this is a horrible overgeneralization, but like- It's okay ... the group of, the group of people who, believed that, Black people are not people, and, and- Mm-hmm ... the values that, we share are complete. But those were the people who generally wanted states to have more power than the federal government, right?
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And, and vice versa. And so this division between... The division of power, between the states and the federal government has a lot of emotional weight for Americans. It goes pretty far back, right? It really goes really far back. Hmm. And, I think it is, it has, I call... I sometimes call it the other F word, federalism.
Hmm. Right. The other F word- Yeah ... for, for folks on the left, because there is this sort of aversion to, Ji- And it's, it... There's perfectly reasonable, rationale for why we have this reaction, right? It's Jim Crow. It's the fact that states, particularly in the South, have used their power as tools of oppression for g- for so many generations.
Nonetheless, we have... We could have been doing both things. We could have been building state-level power and pursuing federal, strategies and infrastructure, but we didn't. Mm-hmm. We just didn't. Yeah. So, we're in this situation where we're coming really far be- from behind in terms of trying to catch up and have the, the...
have enough infrastructure for state-level policy, state-level leaders, to really come up, So that's one thing- Yeah ... that we just structurally is really different from the right. And, and so, I think that that's, that's an important piece of it. And, I think the other piece is just that over time, it's a little bit of a boom and a bust on the left in terms of, if we're in power in DC, no one cares about states.
Hmm. And then, when we're out of power in DC, suddenly the... people rediscover that there- Right ... states have power. and that too has been a hindrance for us because it has not allowed... And when I say us, I just mean the left. To, to, to create lasting and sustained state level infrastructure.
So, we're coming from behind. So y- when, the, the comparisons with ALEC are a little bit, you know, it's a, it's, it is more nuanced than just we didn't think of it first. In fact, we did think of it first. It's called labor organizing, and ALEC exists because they saw us doing it. There you go. but the other thing I was just gonna say is that on our side, we have tended to rely on advocacy organizations to, lobby essentially or be in community with lawmakers and, and, nudge those lawmakers or share with them what they sh- you know, what bills they should be, pursuing.
What we're doing at State Futures and what, ALEC does as well, is have another type of communication channel for policy ideas, which is directly peer-to-peer, lawmaker to lawmaker. So it's great that advocacy organizations exist, and they're an important part of our ecosystem on the left. But we have, I think, left on the table the opportunity to just put legislators in direct communication with each other.
Yeah. Let them talk about the policies that... So we have a healthcare working group, for instance. We have over 200 legislators from across the country from 44 states who participate in a monthly ongoing working group around healthcare access, delivery, and payment issues, right? And the, we'll have a session on, say, medical debt, and all the folks across the country who share our values, who are sponsoring bills on medical debt, will come and talk shop.
Mm-hmm.
Right? Mm-hmm. Like, how's it going on your bill in X state? Well, here's what I found in, when I introduced that last year. Mm-hmm. Here's, here's the opposition I faced, or here's, what we're gonna do differently this time. And that sort of direct communication and that exchange of information in real time and so forth, is just a type of, power that we have, in fact, left off the, left on the table.
Yeah. And that ALEC has harnessed for, I would say, their own nefarious purposes over the past decade.
Now, Section C, Anatomy of the Wave
The focus shifts to who built the wave. Start Making Sense talks with Steve Phillips, author of Brown Is the New White, about how Latino and Black voters powered the Democratic win in Texas. Democracy Now! talks with Cliff Albright of Black Voters Matter and Chris Kromm of the Institute for Southern Studies about investing in the South and the voting barriers that winning didn't remove.
The Texas Earthquake, Plus How Socialism Can Work Part 1 - Start Making Sense - Air Date 11-11-26
A huge number of pundits declared Trump's victory in 2024, even though it was only one and a half percentage points, that that represented a fundamental realignment in American politics, and they said it was led by Latinos switching from the Democrats to the Republicans, especially in Texas, especially in the Rio Grande Valley, which f- four years before, Joe Biden had won those counties by 15 points.
Trump, for the first time, carried all of them in 2024. Now, this year, the shift from Republican to Democratic votes in the midterm nationwide is, what, 14 or 15 points. How much did the governor's race shift in Texas towards the Democrats compared to 2024?
It was a 20, 21-point shift in terms of the, partisan lean, in terms of where things actually went from bef- the prior election to what we actually saw in 2026, which is enormous.
One conclusion some people might draw is that Texas Latinos are a very volatile, group. They flipped gigantically from 2024 to 2026. Maybe they'll flip back again in 2028. What do you think of that possibility?
That's why Gina's race in particular is so strategically significant. If it were just a situation of Latinos repudiating this Trump administration and all of its hostility and all of its attacks, frankly, on, on Latinos and all these other communities, and they voted in favor of a white guy, such as Talarico, you could say, "Well, maybe it would switch back," et cetera.
there's an underlying issue here around Democrats not being willing to be seen as fighting for Latino issues, and so they're not embedded in the psyche and the culture as the champions of Latinos. They've been more concerned about alienating whites who might be mad that they're s- too close to Latinos, and so this has been a fundamental dynamic.
So yes, it could go back and forth- It has somewhat gone back and forth, certainly from, 2020, 2022 when it was Democratic, and then 2024 when there was more of a, a, a move to Trump, and then back here to 2026. But this is why Gina is so significant. This is not just a issue around this set of issues or inflation or even the, ICE crackdowns and whatnot This is somebody people can identify with and who can personify the community.
She comes from the Rio Grande Valley. She is a progressive Latina who has worked in the civil rights, law area, and so she connects culturally as well as politically, and that's the kind of deeper psychological, cultural, social connection that's m- far more enduring and less likely to switch, election to election.
We're told the number one issue for white voters everywhere was the cost of living. Do you think, Latinos care more about high prices than white people? Is that why the turnout was so gigantic or, or was there another issue why Latinos switched from, Trump?
Affordability le- reality is real, but I think it's limited in terms of its...
And so if you look at Latinos, African Americans, actual women, we don't, we leave all, we keep saying, "Oh, let's talk about kitchen table issues." There is a, a, a, a gargantuan racial wealth gap in this country between whites and Latinos, between whites and African Americans. There's a very sizable gender pay gap.
Those are kitchen table issues, but pe- Dem- a lot of Democrats don't wanna lean into them. So I say that to say that affordability has always been an issue for the Latino community. It really has to do with the hostility and the hatred that is co- has been core to Trump's rise, is hatred and hostility and demonization of Mexican Americans in particular.
"They're rapists, they're murderers," in his very first, presidential speech in 2015. And then you take, Stephen Miller and people coming in power, and the- what they've done with ICE and unleashing that on communities and breaking up families, that's just been a, a, a, a, really a bridge too far in terms of assaulting this community and, and, and, and what it is all about.
So I think those issues are actually much more f- core and fundamental on top of the u- underlying affordability piece.
And as far as, 2028 goes, if Trump had learned to moderate his policies regarding Mexican Americans, it's conceivable he might have made some progress. But appointing Stephen Miller, as you say, this is doubling down, so it's likely to get worse and more frightening, to be perfectly frank about it, for Latinos everywhere in the United States, and especially in Texas.
Yes, and, but now there's been so much progress at the state and local level, so if you're just looking at the, the different newspapers in the different counties, that the leadership in Harris County, in Houston, in Austin, it, they are now directing their local police to not cooperate with ICE.
And so they had to before because of Abbott and the, the really repressive state leadership. Harris County, where Houston is, is larger than 25 states. Hmm. And so it's enormous. And so if you can really make some progress there, improve people's lives, back off the repression, it's quite consequential both there and statewide.
And you say in your article in The Nation, "Latinos were the cornerstone of Hinojosa's win, but they were not alone." Please tell us about that.
Texas has actually a, one of the largest concentrations of African Americans in this country, just in terms of the raw numbers of people there. It's a very big state.
And so the Black community, the Black voters went very large. And again, as always happens, Black women are the single most progressive, certainly most Democratic voting bloc, as well as different Bl- as well as Black men fi- following behind them. So she did quite well there. And so that, and there was a larger turnout of Black voters as well, through groups like Texas Organizing Project and oth- and efforts like that.
That was another, a part of the cornerstone. So you have the Latino piece and then you have the African American part, which has always been solidly Democratic, but got bigger in this election, so that made it even more possible.
Just wanna spend one more minute on the fact that Gina Hinojosa is not just Hispanic, she's also a woman.
Oh, exactly, which is something people haven't... And I've actually wondered about, not wondered about, worried about. And there's very t- there's much too little discussion of the, when people say the, that the oftentimes the clearest, most simple answer is the right answer. Donald Trump has run for president three times: twice against a woman, once against a man, and the only time he lost was against the man.
And so if we believe, and I certainly do, that sexism transcends the different demographic groups, that had to come into play as a factor, in 2024 with Kamala. And so it raises the question around, well, what is the potential? And what are, what are the challenges that we fa- the additional challenges in terms of trying to get the electorate to abrace- embrace a woman leader?
And so the fact that Gina actually prevailed and did that is very, very encouraging on multiple different levels. And it is interesting that the prior Democratic governor was also a woman, Ann Richards back in 1994 and whatnot. Hmm. So there is something to be said there.
One more factor. I asked Claude AI how many voters of color in Texas did not vote in 2026, and they came up with an estimate of something like 5 million or 6 million.
I wonder if you agree with that number, and I wonder what you conclude from that number.
So yes, I do agree with that number. We, I, cited the similar numbers off looking at 2024 and 2022 from the census data. They put out voting, statistics, and it's a r- it's been around that number there. So it was a l- probably a little bit small because turnout was higher, but the overall aggregate is big.
So we're in the realm of 5 million people of color who did not vote. And so that is an enormous upside, and it's an, an important lesson too, 'cause right now, what, next week there'll be these moderate Democrats gathering, talking about where do we go from here. there's all these efforts to continuing to try to woo more of the moderate, and if there are such a thing, but the whites who are not with us, whereas the upside is enormous.
And so one of the... Like, there's a group being Texas For All that's done, working on a c- a, a, a precinct captain program to be able to get as many people out to vote. That's the future in terms of locking this down solidly, is having every single precinct in the state have a precinct captain so we can get those 5 million more voters out, and that's also will help flip the state Senate, which will then make Tex- Texas a blue trifecta state, which will be enormous as well.
Purple Mississippi? Overcoming GOP Voter Suppression, Black Voters Power Dem Wins Across the South Part 2 - Democracy Now! - Air Date 11-5-26
Cliff Albright, I know you have to leave in a second. You're back in Atlanta, Georgia, where Keisha Lance Bottoms is now the first African American woman governor in the country. Mm ... and you've just been in Mississippi. One of the most remarkable, shifts in this country is the massive voter turnout.
In many countries, many more people vote percentage-wise than in the United States, but it is growing here. if you can talk about, also what this lack of Democratic establishment support has meant, for Collum, but also Angie Nixon, who came so close, to defeating the incumbent in Florida without that support.
as Collum has pointed out, if only she had had that from the beginning. your final comments on what you're taking away from this election, as you say, in Mississippi, they've accepted that Collum has won, even if the rest of the country doesn't, and if you think it could be stopped. here you have Cindy Hyde-Smith, who prevented C- Collum, she might be sorry now, from being, appointed to the federal bench.
She blocked Biden's nomination
Yeah, I think that, so a couple of things on, on the Georgia thing, in addition to Ke- Keisha, becoming governor, all the way down the ballot to the point that Chris was just making, all the way down the ballot, it's, it's, it's almost every state office in the state of Georgia is now going to be led by a Black woman: labor commissioner, agriculture, educa- all the way down except for lieutenant governor, where, where Josh won that one.
But, so it's, it's absolutely remarkable, and it's a sign of what could happen all across the South with the proper investment. What's been happening in Georgia, in 2020, in 2022 with Warnock winning again this year, this has been from years of investment, the kind of investment that Mississippi, Louisiana, Florida is not see- Florida is insane in the way that people have turned their backs on the state of Florida and declared that it was hopeless even, even after Andrew Gillum came close in 2018.
and then it just, people just wrote it off. And for Angie to do what she did, and shout-out to her, to, on almost little, very little investment, really says what the potential is in the South. We're hoping that the narrative or the question, the debate around what strategy makes sense in the South, do you, do you invest in Black and brown voters and mobilize that base, right?
Or do you continue to look for these unicorn Trump voters that swing back and forth? This year should really put that debate to, to an end, but I have a feeling it's going to, to continue. The last thing I'm gonna say, Amy, is this, and this is very important. With all these victories, there's a risk that people lose sight of the structural barriers that still exist, the voter suppression that is still taking place.
I know the Mississippi coalition is very insistent that people hear that story about things that still went wrong in this, in this election, and this goes for across the South. And a lot of times what happens is when we win against all odds, that people say, "Oh, the voter suppression wasn't that bad." They, they said this about Warnock in '22.
They said, "Oh, I guess that voter suppression bill wasn't that bad." No, we're able to overcome the suppression, but that doesn't mean that it's not a structural barrier. The racial gerrymandering that took place has still given Republicans a structural edge that's been covered in a wave year, but it's still something that's gotta be corrected.
The Supreme Court's decision has still got to be fixed. We still need voting rights legislation. and that with investment means there's nothing that we can't achieve all across the South.
A- and Chris, Crump, I wanted to ask you if you could talk a little bit about what's happened in North Carolina, in this election?
Remarkable. Not only did you have at the top of the ticket, it looks like Roy Cooper is gonna win by 19 to 20 points when all is said and done in terms of counting the ballots. But again, you go down the list, four of the biggest upsets in US congressional races were in North Carolina. It looks like at this point that we're gonna go from a delegation that despite extreme gerrymandering, was a 10-4 in favor delegation, in favor of Republicans, will flip to a delegation that's 10-4 in favor of Democrats.
Incredible stories like the longtime Speaker of the House, Tim Moore, who created his own district through redistricting so he could win, was upset by a Black woman in District 14. In the mountains of North Carolina where Hurricane Helene had devastated the region, you had a, a farmer, Ager, who is gonna, is, won that race in District 11.
just down the ballot, upset after upset, and it really showed that it was a combination of the political environment, h- how at the top of the ballot, the excitement and the investment that happened, but also some solid grassroots organizing, historic Black and Latino voter turnout. it really was the perfect storm, and it showed what's possible.
And again, I think this is a story a lot of other Southern states could look like a North Carolina with the right investment, with the right attention. And so the story of North Carolina, I think, is one that people should be paying attention to across the country and also about what's possible in the South.
And Chris Crum, we recently spoke to Justin Pearson. Justin Pearson, who ran for Congress from, Memphis. he really took on, the, data center there, as did his brother. He did lose, but he lost by just 2,000 votes in his gerrymandered district. So even in that case, can you talk about the significance of this in Tennessee?
Well, this is what's so important to understand is that for all the wins, and there were, Democrats held on to 40 congressional seats, House seats. They are gonna flip about 10 to 14 seats. I think that number's growing every day as new results come in, but it's gonna be about another 14 seats.
If you think about how much bigger that wave would've been without the extreme gerrymandering, without the extreme voter restrictions that have been seen throughout the South, that wave would've been even bigger, and it really points to the importance of voting rights. And Pearson's a great example of this.
there's over 30 data centers in the Memphis area. He is an out- a leader in that fight and talking about what the implications are for the community. And so he didn't make it to the finish line, but there were so many candidates like that in places where they were able to really move the needle.
when you saw this in- incredible uptick in the electorate of Black and Latino voters, a real shift, and even if they get, didn't get to the finish line, I hope the overall story people see is that the South is increasingly competitive and that there's a real opportunity for engaging more voters and really pushing the region in a more progressive direction.
And Finally, Section D, Lessons and Warnings
Most of this section reaches back to before the 2006 wave. It starts in June 2005 on NPR's News & Notes, with Howard Dean, then chair of the Democratic National Committee, making the case for competing in all fifty states. From October 2006, Democracy Now! talks with Matt Taibbi about a Congress that shut Democrats out. Ring of Fire, co-hosted then by Robert F. Kennedy Jr., yes, that RFK Jr., interviewed former congresswoman Elizabeth Holtzman about why an impeachment has to be bipartisan. We finish back in 2026 on Start Making Sense, with Bhaskar Sunkara of The Nation on what it'll take to make these gains last.
Programming note on two of the voices you're about to hear. Matt Taibbi was a respected working journalist who then really made a name for himself during the economic crisis of 2008 and 2009, very astutely analyzing the role of the big banks in destroying our democracy and economy while using curse words. In more recent years, he's better known for helping Elon Musk as one of his handpicked reporters by coordinating with and distributing Musk's "Twitter Files," about claimed "political bias" on the platform in the years before his takeover. That arrangement, passing on information from a source with clear ulterior motives without corroboration, went precisely against the kind of journalistic ethics Taibbi had previously claimed to adhere to, so he's pretty much fallen out of favor in any mainstream or progressive media circles.
RFK Jr. was one of the co-hosts of Ring of Fire Radio back in the day, and I really couldn't have imagined that I would ever need to make a disclaimer like this back when I was using clips from his interviews: We didn't know at the time that in the '90s he'd cut off the head of a beached whale with a chainsaw, strapped it to the roof of his car, and drove with it while whale juices dripped down through the window and his children wore plastic bags on their heads with mouth holes cut out to protect themselves. Also, the segment you'll hear was likely recorded years before a brain worm ate part of his brain and died. It was also recorded even more years before he picked up a dead bear cub on the side of the road, drove it into New York City, and dumped it in Central Park, staging it as a cyclist hit-and-run because he thought it'd be fun.
Had I known any of these things either had happened or would happen in the future back in 2006, I think I would have reconsidered using these people as a source. We regret the temporal error, but also, I think these segments stand up just fine as they are for re-airing as long as you know to not trust a word either of them says today.
A Talk with DNC Head Howard Dean - News & Notes - Air Date 6-13-2005
I think that's a, a chronic problem.
And one thing, I may be controversial, but I, my allegiance is to people outside the Beltway. We can't win elections unless we talk about what we can fix in American society, how to move America forward. We have to have a sense of optimism and vision, and that's what Americans have always thrived on.
That's why we're a great country, and we, I wanna be a great country again
You mentioned the word controversial. Some have suggested that you, for a politician, particularly in the seat you sit in now, can be and are being too frank. Is that a problem? I
don't think there's any such thing as being too frank in politics.
If you see what's going on in Washington today, the majority leader of the House has been reprimanded three times by the Ethics Committee. He's on his way to his fourth reprimand. The administration has concealed, reports that show that adding mercury to the air is gonna poison our kids and our, and our pregnant wives.
the administration is lying to Congress about how much programs cost, like the drug programs. We gotta have some honesty back in government, and, we need a little frankness in this place, and there are people who are frank on both sides of the aisle, and I think those are the folks that, that we really need to, to lead the country.
Yet you have made, many on your side of the aisle a little nervous with this frankness, if we're going to stay with that word. are you disappointed in that?
No. I think, it is true that it's not in, in anybody's best interest to have me be the center of attention. That's why the Republicans are fanning this so much.
The Republicans would much rather make this about the chairman of the Democratic Party instead of Social Security and jobs and, and a strong defense. We have a Republican administration who has sent 138,000 troops to Iraq and ignored two much more powerful, enemies, Iran and North Korea. These people are out of touch with what we need for a strong defense.
We have an administration that's trying to cut benefits for middle class and working Americans while they have $106 billion in tax cuts for their campaign contributors.
Yet you talk about r- Republicans fanning the flames and keeping this, i- in the news, in the headlines, if you will. Let me give you a quote, that you've been dealing with quite a bit over the course of the last week or so, and that is that, you made the suggestion that the Republican Party was pretty much a, white and Christian party.
People, like Barack Obama, the, senator from Illinois, have suggested that that is a case of using religion to divide, and he felt that you needed to back off of that statement
a bit. I, I think part of that is that the, there's an enormous amount of distortion about that statement. I don't back off that statement for a minute because it happens to be true.
I don't think there's anything the matter with white Christians, at least I hope there isn't, 'cause I am one. I'm simply pointing out that the Republican Party is making a big deal about diversity when, in fact, they don't have any. John Danforth, former United States senator, Republican senator, George Bush's representative to the United Nations, criticized his party for being a tool of the conservative religious right and saying that the Republican Party h- isn't what it used to be.
I think that's right. I don't think there's anything controversial about that. And when it's people like Senator Obama refer to that, what they're referring to is quotes that the news, the news media truncates and says, "Well, Governor Dean said this insulting Christians." Well, I never said any such thing insulting Christians, and I think what folks, in Washington have to learn is never respond to a press quote that you haven't seen yourself without talking to the person first, because often what the press tells you I said is a great deal different than I actually said.
When you talk about diversity, the Democratic Party can show certainly, disproportionately, a large amount of African Americans in that party, yet there are many African Americans elected and just your everyday average voter who will suggest that there is no power given to the Black muscle.
Well, first of all, I don't think that is true.
I do think that the Democratic Party has historically, recently taken African American voters for granted, and I don't think that, many, Democratic officials understand the changes that are going on in the Black community. There's a whole new generation of Black voters who are appreciative of what we did in civil rights, but they're, they're too young to remember that.
They didn't go through that, and what they wanna know is the same as every other voter wants to know. How, how are you gonna make it easier for me to run a business? what are you gonna do to help, help me with my, kids getting through college? These are things every American wants to know, and I think we haven't moved fast enough to understand, the, the evolution of the political dialogue in the Black community.
So I, I do think that's a concern. I think the claims of the Republicans a- about, the fact that, African Americans don't have muscle and that they're gonna be a party that's gonna be open to them, that is absolute nonsense. How can you appeal to the African American community if you're cutting the African American community's health insurance, if you're cutting their Social Security, they're cutting their benefits?
We have people in Congress, 41 members of the Black Caucus, every single one is a Democrat. The path to political power and the path to power in general in this country for Black Americans is through the Democratic Party. th- and this is not just about Black Americans. This is the same true as of, of Hispanic Americans.
The future for Hispanic Americans is in the Democratic Party. Antonio Villaraigosa, the new mayor of the second-largest city, in America. The truth is that while we're not perfect w- and we know that we have to reach out now and not wait till four weeks before the next, next election, and that's just exactly what we're gonna do, that we have historically, represented the best interests of the, of the African American community, and today we're gonna learn how to do that even better.
Yet, Governor, many African Americans that I speak with, whether it be on the streets as I travel, in a barbershop, what have you, they don't seem to have the same connection with this party that they did in times past. And I'll be frank with you, off the record, there are some of those people, in the Congressional Black Caucus who have said to me, again, off the record, that the Democratic Party is looking to them to, add anything other than that Black face.
Well, that's totally untrue. If you look at, just look at the Democratic National Committee, what we've done here, we totally flattened the administrative structure. I have seven or eight people reporting to me of every, color, creed, so forth and so on, and in fact, there are a significant number of African Americans who now have management positions in, and are in the room when the decisions are made.
That's the first time we've had that in the DNC other than when Ron Brown was chairman. The people who make the decisions at the Democratic National Committee, are the most diverse group of people you've ever seen. And my philosophy on affirmative action is it's a nice program, but if you really want affirmative action, you put people in positions of power when they-- where-- so they can hire people.
That's how you get diversity
What are the thought of, going back to what we initially talked about, too much rhetoric coming out of Washington, that voters hear about the, we wanna raise the, the, the moral fiber of the country, we wanna cut taxes, we want schools perfect. We know this, but people aren't necessarily seeing the rubber meet the road.
What can you do to make sure that the words, meet the meaning?
I think we gotta talk about moral values as to... Somebody came up to me the other day, a, a member of the African American community, and said to me, Governor, what are we gonna do? My pastor is now saying that, that maybe we should be ro- ro- voting Republican, and I disagree with that."
And I said, "Well, here's what you should do. W- go see your pastor and say, 'Look, let's look at moral values. The Democrats think it's a moral value to make sure that everybody has health insurance. The Democrats think it's a moral value never to let a child go to bed hungry at night. The v- Democrats think it's a moral value that you do not exclude people from voting by making them wait for eight hours, to cast their ballot.'
That's what we believe are moral values." I think for the African American community, and for the community in general in America, that moral values are more, than a woman's right to make up her own mind about her healthcare or civil rights for gay Americans. I think there are other moral values, and we're gonna agree, I think, and most Americans, especially in the Black community, are gonna agree with Democrats on the majority of our moral values, and we wanna make sure that people understand what we're gonna do.
Now, when we get back in power, if we don't deliver on healthcare, and if we don't deliver on better public education and jobs, then we ought not to be in power.
You seem fairly, fairly confident that, Dems will get back in power, and we all understand, those of us who've watched Washington, and I lived there for almost a decade, you understand that everything goes in cycles.
but there are those watchers, those pundits, who suggest that the Dems, perhaps more than any other time in recent memory, just don't have a game plan. They are too fractured.
I think that has been true, but I think it's gonna be less true, and by the time we face the '06 elections, we are gonna have a national message again for the first time in a long time.
We're gonna be in all 50 states. I've, by the end of this month, I will have been in 32 out of the 50 states. The majority of states I will have been in, I believe, are so-called red states, are Republican states. There are states that we can win back that voted for George Bush, states where Democrats have done well, Kansas, with a Democratic governor, Virginia, with a Democratic governor, Louisiana, with a Democratic governor.
We're investing money in Mississippi. I think it's outrageous for our party to write off the South, We're not gonna do that anymore. We had five wins, this past election. They just had their municipal elections down there. Five new, Democratic, mayors, in different cities, and that's because of African American voters, and, and if we're gonna be serious about the African Amer- American community, we're gonna be serious about the South.
Worst Congress Ever - Democracy Now! - Air Date 10-27-06
Whatever the outcome, the 110th US Congress will open session on January 3rd, 2007. While the country's attention remains focused on the upcoming elections, few are considering the current state of the legislative branch.
How did the 109th Congress perform? Well, the cover story of this week's Rolling Stone magazine takes on that issue. The article is called The Worst Congress Ever: How Our National Legislature Has Become a Stable of Thieves and Perverts in Five Easy Steps. It's written by Matt Taibbi, a contributing editor for the magazine.
He joins us now in studio. Welcome to Democracy Now, Matt.
Thanks for having me.
Why worst?
Well, there's so many reasons why this is the worst. the easiest ones to talk about statistically is just the mere laziness factor. you've heard of the famous Do Nothing Congress from 1948. this c- this, Congress smashed the record that was set by that Congress for fewest days ever worked by a Congress.
That Congress worked a total of two hundred and forty-nine days between the House and the Senate. This Congress worked two hundred and eighteen days total, so they beat that record by a month, and, even those two hundred and eighteen days, were made up a, a lot of fragmentary days. So the House, for instance, had nine days that were less than eleven minutes long, and the Senate had three days less than one minute.
So this is easily the laziest Congress of all time, if nothing else.
But when they are in session, they've, done quite a bit to change the way the Congress operates, right? what about the, the rules changes that you talk about in your article?
Well, there's been a lot of changes just in the way that bills get heard, that bills get talked about.
One of the things that this Congress has done is drastically reduce the number of what's called open rules, and open rules are bills that make it to the House floor in a form that allows congressmen to debate them and offer amendments to them. there was a time back in the late '70s when about 75% of the bills that made it to the floor were open rules.
now, it should be said that, that number continued to decline while the Democrats still controlled Congress. By the time they, the Democrats ceded control in '94, that number was about 30%. This year, there were no open rules except for appropriations bills, which are always open. So, we've basically seen the last of those kinds of openly debated bills in Congress.
Rule by cabal, what do you mean?
Well, the Republicans have, have basically figured out a way to totally exclude the, the, the minority from the process. obviously, if you have the majority in Congress, you're going to have most of the influence anyway. But traditionally in Congress, there's been, a, a power-sharing agreement.
bills were usually, made up in, in session between, the mino- minority and the majority, and the, the two parties always worked together to make up major legislation And that's, that's done now in Congress. That doesn't happen anymore. a great example is that, conference committees where when you have, the conference that, hammers out the differences between the Senate and the House versions of bills.
Traditionally, both parties work in that conference committee to, create the final version of the bill. Well, this Congress has pioneered a new method of handling, the conferences. What they'll do is they'll have... By law, they have to have one conference that includes Dem- Democrats. They'll have a five-minute meeting where the, the Democrats are there.
They'll take a picture, and then they'll kick the Democrats out, and they'll hold the real meeting later, and they won't tell the Democrats where it is. And you get this situation that results, it's, it's really like a, an elementary school thing where they won't tell the Democrats where it is, so the Democratic minority member will have to go around Congress literally searching for the conference, knocking on doors saying, "Are you inside?"
there
was- Give us an example.
There was a famous example where the Ways and Means Committee, uh, chaired by Bill Thomas, a congressman from California, he didn't tell the ranking minority member, who was Charlie Rangel here from New York, he didn't tell him where the conference was. and Rangel went around the con- the Congress looking for this, this, conference, knocking on doors, and he finally finds it.
He knocks on the door, and the Republicans hid behind the door, pretending that they weren't inside. Literally, like little kids, they hid it, they hid in there. the one, one, congressional aid said it was like the old SNL skit Land Shark, where, Charlie Rangel was the land shark. The Republicans wouldn't, wouldn't open the door.
They finally opened it, and Thomas says to Rangel, he says, "Sorry, this is only for the coalition of the willing." and he, basically kicked Rangel out of the room. Actually, I'm sorry, they packed up their stuff, and they left, and they held the conference someplace else. And this kind of stuff happens at every level, at every stage of the congressional process now.
So everywhere where you used to have meetings between the two parties where they would work things out, the Republicans just, disallow, participation by the, the Democrats. In
your article, you, you, paint a p- portrait There are many of these congressional staffers that are just lost now, the Democratic staffers, with nothing to do and, and they haven't seen the sun in seven years- -you say of some of them.
And w-what's the impact o-o-on the Democrats of this kind of a total, uh, a not just embarrassment, but-
Humiliation ...
humiliation, yes.
Yeah. It's, it's completely changed the way that Congress does business, and this is something that's difficult to quantify. But again, Congress used to be a collegial place.
It used to be a place where, Democrats and Republicans, they may be, they may be different ideologically, but they used to hang out together on the weekends. They used to play golf, together on the weekends, and that was where a lot of things got worked out socially, was, outside of Congress.
They would have lunch together. They would, they would socialize together with their wives. That doesn't happen anymore, and there's a complete antipathy now between the parties to a degree that the new generation, even of Democrats, doesn't even understand the theory of, of communicating with the Republicans about things.
Rangel, this congressman from New York, tells a great story about how, uh, I guess it was last year, he went up to go talk to Clay Shaw, who was a Republican from Florida, and he just... He had heard Shaw was sick, and he wanted to go and s- pay his respects to him. And he goes and says hello to Shaw on the other end of the floor, and when Rangel gets back, one of the Demo- young Democrats leans over to him and he goes, "What the hell was that about?"
In other words, the young Democrats don't even understand why you would talk to a Republican, even socially. And this is... so you have the new generation of congressmen that doesn't even un- doesn't even know how to work together.
Matt Taibbi, what happened when the Democrats wanted to have a hearing on the Patriot Act?
Oh, well, again, this is another way that they exclude Democrats from the process. typically, congressmen are allowed to hold hearings, even the minority, members of a committee, are allowed to hold hearings whenever you... well, whenever you want to. But, the, Republican chairmen have, decided to make it as difficult as possible for Democrats to do this.
So in this instance, the Democrats wanted to hold a, a meeting, excuse me, on the Patriot Act, i-in the Judiciary Committee. So they asked, James Sensenbrenner, who is the, chairman. He's this, famously dictatorial congressman from Wisconsin. And, he said, "Yeah, sometime in the future," but he didn't tell them when.
Then one Thursday night, late on Thursday night, he says, "Okay, you're on for, for tomorrow morning at nine o'clock." So the Democrats have to scramble all their witnesses, get everything prepared overnight, but they do. They get everything done, and by nine o'clock the next morning, they're ready to hold their mirror, their hearing.
Well, they start having their hearing, and Sensenbrenner decides that he's bored and he wants to leave, and he tries to gavel the hearing to a close before everyone's done. Democrats said, "No, we're not finished." So, Sensenbrenner, that wasn't good enough for him. So he literally got up Walked across the room, shut the lights off, shut the microphones off, and closed the door behind them, leaving the Democrats with all their witnesses, which included people from groups like Amnesty International and other groups just sitting there in the dark.
again, this is, this is stuff that you would expect in an elementary school, not, not in the Congress. I used to live in Russia. Even the Duma wasn't this bad.
Bush Impeachment - Ring of Fire - Air Date 10-21-06
Right now, we're back with former Congress member Elizabeth Holtzman, who served on the committee that voted to impeach President Nixon. She's now arguing that the current president should be removed from office, and she lays out a very compelling legal case for that in The Impeachment of George Bush, a book she co-authored with Cynthia Cooper.
Liz, you lay out a number of indictments w-- that you believe that he could be impeached for. One of those is, to me, the the least convincing one, is the, the mismanagement and the indifference to human life in, in Katrina, in his response to Katrina. Presidents make mistakes all the time, and, this one was a horrible one.
But, is it the kind of thing that you can impeach somebody for?
Well, I think you raise a good question, Bobby, and, I struggled with this. What you have here is the President was told personally, although he initially denied it, but there's a video. The President was personally told that the levees could be breached in, New Orleans, and he was told by Brownie, "You've done a heck of a job, Brownie," who was the head of FEMA, that there was going to be a catastrophe.
The President, under a system of laws with regard to disaster relief, and this is according to a study that was done by the Republican-controlled Congress Is really the commander-in-chief of disaster relief. In other words, he is the one who could mobilize, in the end, all the resources of the federal government.
And the video of that meeting shows him saying basically nothing about it. He didn't ask one question when he had the special power. No one else in the country had the power he did to mobilize the military, mobilize emergency resources, mobilize medical assistance, mobilize food, a-and try to minimize to the fullest extent possible the calamity that was about to happen.
Now, I guess people could disagree because it's not anything like any of the other impeachment articles that were voted during Nixon. But it does strike me that when a president is constitutionally responsible for taking care that the laws are faithfully executed, that you can't just walk away and go on vacation when you know that something drastic is about to happen.
I think, you just kinda have to give orders and find out what's going on and take charge, and he didn't.
one of the things that you've pointed out is the judicious use of the impeachment remedy in the past. As you point out in the book, it became a, a partisan tool following the Civil War.
But, in modern history, for example, with the impeachment you involved with, with Richard Nixon, it was a bipartisan effort. Right. And one of the things that John Dean, who's I, I think ended up being a friend of yours, which is a odd friendship at this point, one of the things he's pointed out is that Goldwater and a number of other high-level Republicans approached Nixon in the White House and asked him to resign to avoid the constitutional crisis.
During the Reagan administration, the Democrats agreed to refrain from impeachment even though Reagan was caught red-handed lying about the Iran-Contra issue. if-- as soon as Baker came into the White House and made a personal commitment to restore order to the White House.
So there's been this history of, of a bipartisan effort to avoid this kind of constitutional crisis in the past. But this has changed in recent years, hasn't it, with this Congress and with the Clinton impeachment?
Yes, I think that the Congress... I, I, I think, for example, the, the Republicans have failed in any way, shape, or form, although they control the House and the Senate, to investigate what happened, fully what happened with regard to the, the deception of, of the Iraq war.
fully to investigate the issue of torture and detainee torture. In fact, this new law, the Military Tribunal Commission law, actually provides immunity for, any government official, whether it's the president or a CIA inter-interrogator who violated the US War Crimes Act, without debate, without analysis, without hearings, without public discussion.
I, I... What, what troubles me is that we ha-- the Congress has been almost as bad as the President in terms of failing its responsibility. But impeachment will not work, in my opinion, unless it is bipartisan, and unless the country, the people of this country, understand that what's at stake is preserving the rule of law and making sure that a president of the United States doesn't declare himself above the law.
Because if this president can violate the law on wiretapping and the law on mistreatment of prisoners and, deceive the country into going into war, well, what will the next president do, and how much worse will that be?
How come there's no congressman really talking about this, and do you see any hope that that's gonna happen?
It's not surprising. first of all, I should say John Conyers, in fact, did introduce a resolution which has been co-sponsored by thirty m-- seven or thirty-nine members of Congress, calling for an inquiry into whether the President committed impeachable offenses.
And I think Russ Feingold in the Senate.
Had a censure resolution, not impeachment. You can't actually... Probably he would-
Congress has to legally impeach first, right?
Well, yes. And, and, also there's-- Right. The House has to impeach first before the Senate acts, so you couldn't even introduce an impeachment resolution in the Senate. I think if the Democrats do take over the House and the Senate, there will be serious inquiry into this, and there should be.
But it needs to be done, if it's going to be done, in a totally fair a-and bipartisan manner, and it has to follow the standards that were set during the Nixon impeachment inquiry, which, we bent over backwards in that to be fair to the President, to make sure that his point of view was fully heard, to make sure that it was bipartisan.
We could have rammed it through, and it never would've been persuasive to the American people, and you can't remove an elected president unless the American people agree to that. And that's really what the Nixon impeachment showed. The, partisan impeachments of Andrew Johnson and Bill Clinton showed that those are just not gonna succeed because the American people will not tolerate, overturning, an evo-- a vote bipartisan group.
But on the other hand, the American people also have to say that we want to preserve our constitutional democracy, and power is in their hands now.
The Texas Earthquake, Plus How Socialism Can Work Part 2 - Start Making Sense - Air Date 11-11-26
A few facts. In addition to gaining control of both houses of Congress, Democrats gained six governorships. Now Democrats will lead 9 of the 10 most populous states, will govern states representing 75% of Americans. Democrats also won six new state government trifectas, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan, Minnesota, and out west, Nevada and Arizona.
nearly every group of voters moved towards Democrats. The biggest shifts came among Latinos, Asians, young people, and, and rural voters. So what do Democrats need to do now?
Yeah, I think for one, we should just obviously be excited about what's, what's happened. the victory in Mississippi especially, and it looks like it's, it's headed toward a, a victory there, is one of the biggest triumphs of the broad left in the US since Reconstruction.
It's, it's a symbolism of obviously we know that the economic part of the revolution needs to be finished, but the long battle against Jim Crow, the long battle to have people see each other as, as, as equals in society, the long struggle of racial justice, it is a real victory in that regard. And I think from a lot of the left that has grown up in this more pessimistic environment where we've been unable to say yes, the election of Barack Obama and him winning a state like Indiana in 2008 actually means something as far as barometer of our success.
this, this victory, especially in Mississippi, does matter. And broadly, the, the vi- the victories in Texas does, does matter. Where I put some caution, in the mix is just simply the environment was so favorable for Democrats, not because of the seats that were contested and they had a pretty rough map in the Senate, but simply because of how unpopular Trump, Trump is.
approval ratings by some measures in the low 30s, a really unpopular Iran war, spiking diesel prices, which, which matters a lot in these, those rural areas, gas prices, the general sense that he's not delivering on his promises. This yielded a really favorable terrain for any opposition party, and I think more work needs to be done to make sure the Democratic Party gains stick, particularly in rural and semi-rural areas where Democrats were lose, used to losing 30-70.
And this election is proof that if you lose 40-60, you could be competitive statewide in a lot of these places. And this isn't even a me making a radical socialist point. This is saying, let's look back to the Howard Dean 50 state strategy. Let's look to the people, wherever they were in the spectrum, that decided to invest in Mississippi, thought it was winnable, people who cared about- The races in Kentucky, which would've been winnable, in Tennessee, which would've been winnable if, if there was more investment.
I don't care where they are in the spectrum, I think those are the voices to elevate and where the focus of the party should be, going forward. But obviously it's very exciting. It's now easier to see the map to get to 58, 59 solid Democrats in the Senate in the next cycle, and maybe you could poach, like some grand compromise the labor could make with the Josh Hawleys of the world and, and others.
Not that I generally s- support working with those people, but, if you get, if you get something like the PRO Act passed, I think it could really change the, the game as far as the organized workers' movement in this country. So, so it's, it's very exciting. I'm much more optimistic about the direction this c- country can go in than I was a month ago.
Yeah. Your book, The Blueprint: How Socialism Can Work in the Real World, starts with the fact that capitalism is not working for most people. That's pretty obvious, but the big question of course is what is to be done? And there's one preliminary objection to the whole project of a blueprint for socialism.
It goes all the way back to Marx. He never wrote anything like the blueprint. His view was that the workers themselves should decide what they needed and wanted, and it would be a s- a mistake, it would be wrong, it would be undemocratic for leaders and intellectuals to tell workers what they needed. why do you disagree with that?
Why do you think socialists owe people a concrete model?
the whole idea of a blueprint today is to tell people that in fact, despite the past failures of different models of socialism, the barriers to constructing a better world are political, not technical. And that's a great start of a conversation if you're, you're a socialist.
It's easy enough to see what the minimum program of socialism is. Robust public system of social support. We all know it. Medicare for all, free childcare, free public college, strong unions, higher minimum wages, decent housing, clean water and air. Basically what the social democracies of Denmark, Norway, and Sweden achieved at their peak.
You call them the most livable societies that human beings ever built. But there's one huge thing missing even from Scandinavian socialism from the viewpoint of socialists. Tell us about that.
Ultimately, it left huge chunks of the economy in private hands. So there should be a couple objections come to this in the socialist perspective.
We, as socialists, don't believe in the division of society between those who own and those who have to work for them. We think that in those conditions, even entering into a free contract as a laborer is a contract made under duress, a worker starved bargain. Furthermore, we believe that there's tons of capacity that ordinary workers have to make decisions about production, to participate in the democratic governance of a firm.
So we f- we favor instead of private capitalist ownership, labor managed firm purely on that normative basis. Now, there's a lot of people who say, "Well, my objection to capitalism is mostly distributional. It's mostly about the outcomes of poverty, of neglect, of, women not being able to be truly free because they don't have access to, to childcare, for instance, and, and that shaping w- their w- o- outlook in life and their opportunities afforded to them, or, someone being perpetually unemployed and not being able to fully participate in civil society because they're always worried about, underemployment and, and, and not being, having the money to participate in civil society."
For those people, I would say Well, I, one, perfectly agree with all the social democratic objections to capitalism, but even if you just want a robust welfare state that expands and continues to expand to meet- meets people's needs and as we have more productivity gains is, we plow more of that, those gains into the welfare state, well, you're, you're still allowing a class of people who have a vested interest in keeping people insecure enough to accept unacceptable bargains at work.
So my- in my view, the socialist project is about both voice, voice in the workplace, voice in civil society, the democratic voice aspect, but it's also about giving people exit options, and under capitalism, those exit options are, are, are limited, and by, simply the fact that, that ordinary people have to work for a living and are dependent on jobs created disproportionately by private capitalists, we, can't have a true democracy.
So voice, democracy in the workplace, worker control, that's really the heart of the social- socialist idea. The first problem there is the conflict between what consumers want, now we're calling it affordability, and what workers want, basically higher wages. What's your proposal about how that should be decided?
Well, simply the market mechanism does in fact resolve this. People, are given choice as consumers to, look for items on the basis of q- quality and also cost, and to pick between an array of choices. I think that's something that actually works quite well in capitalism.
The problem with this consumer choice in capitalism is obviously our grossly unequal distribution of income, which a socialist society could resolve through taxes and transfers and to g- guaranteeing a right to work and all sorts of things. But the actual choice, and also the fact that these choices are private, d- does, does matter.
But, workers simply would compete with, other firms, other labor-managed firms for market share. they would find their market niche, they would grow and expand and become more efficient, or they will contract and, and fail, and I think this is the market mechanism actually working well and serving, egalitarian, outcomes.
That's going to be it for today.
Be sure to check out our link in bio right in the show notes for all the ways to follow us on social platforms, contact us, and support everything Best of the Left, including membership and one-time donations.
The additional sections of the show included clips from;
The Brian Lehrer Show
What A Day
Why, America with Leeja Miller
Baby Boom! Lawyered
The BradCast
Democracy Now!
Start Making Sense
News & Notes
and Ring of Fire
Further details are in the show notes.
Thanks to everyone for listening. Thanks to Deon and Erin for their production work for the show. Thanks to Ben, our Swiss Army Knife fixer behind the scenes. And thanks to those of you who already support the show by becoming a member, purchasing gift memberships, or making one-time donations.
You'll find the link to support us in the show notes along with links to join our Patreon and Discord communities for free where you can also continue the discussion. And don't forget to follow us on all the social media platforms as I have relaunched our social media strategy!
So coming to you from far outside the conventional wisdom of Washington, DC, my name is Jay! And this has been the Best of the Left podcast, coming to you twice weekly, thanks entirely to the members and donors to the show, from bestoftheleft.com.


Showing 1 reaction